Editorial Reviews for Nominees
|
|
|
Editorial Reviews for Nominees
|
|
|
|
Score: 92/100 (9.2 out of 10)
Exploring Beauty with Photographer Samantha Moller Lopez, Volume 1 is a beautiful photography collection featuring spectacular nature photos by Samantha Moller Lopez. The book is credited to Dow Creative Enterprises (presumably functioning as the corporate publisher/author) and set to "Song of Nature" by Ralph Waldo Emerson. "Song of Nature" is an inspired choice of text, a sweeping meditation on nature as the original creator and teacher. Emerson’s lines move from the grand and cosmic to the small and intimate, talking about stars and oceans in one breath, then apples, flowers, and dew in the next. The book presents the poem one short line at a time, spread across the pages, which slows your reading down and turns each line into something you can sit with. Instead of rushing through a block of verse, you are nudged to ponder every phrase in conversation with a single image. It's Emerson. It's practically perfect. Emerson's poem is an extraordinary literary example. With that said, we can't credit Lopez or Dow for the beauty of those passages and lines for obvious reasons. We can, however, credit them for providing fitting photographs that illustrate the different passages and lines. And that, to be honest, is hit or miss. There are times when the photographs match the lines and passages, and there are times when they just seem to be there, arbitrarily. Let's start with some the times that the photographs fit the poem... On page 4, an actual photo of the moon on a visibly cloudy evening accompanies the line "The sportive sun, the gibbous moon." Fittingly, it appears to be a gibbous moon. On page 12, there's a magnificent photograph of a stairway leading up and to the right with a marvelous ray of light coming down through the branches and leaves. The accompanying line is: "I sit by the shining Fount of Life." The only photo that would probably be more perfect is if the stairway were replaced with a fountain. On page 31, there's an image of a blooming flower with star-like rays radiating from the seedlings. The matching line is: "Tricked out in star and flower" On page 45, a fitting image of a tall tree accompanies the line "The summit of the whole." A tall mountain like Fuji probably would've worked too, but this is fine. On page 59, a photo of a deer aligns with the line "My creatures travail and wait." On page 67, probably the most beautiful and visually striking page in the book, a photo of a flowing body of light-blue water sparsely concealed behind the cover of green trees, a white path leading to the water. On page 75, the accompanying line "And mix the bowl again" is paired with a body of water wrapped in a circular ring, almost like a bowl. And there are a bunch of other examples like the pink rose on page 84 with "And the fresh rose on yonder thorn." That's awesome. However, there are a lot of photos in here that either seem redundant (very similar to others in the collection), superfluous, or that don't seem to fit the line at all. There are multiple shots of bamboo forests, multiple stone paths through trees, and multiple shrine gates from only slightly different angles. The first time you see a bamboo corridor or a tunnel of torii, it feels magical and fresh. By the third or fourth time, the impact starts to fade and the book begins to feel padded rather than tightly curated. A slimmer, more ruthlessly edited set of images would probably have made the strongest ones shine even brighter. There are also multiple shots of the exact same tree with the white papers hanging around it. Furthermore, there are pairings that require a lot of interpretive gymnastics. Lines that reference specific places or ideas, such as the Judaean manger, Nile, or the Academe, are sometimes matched with images that feel only vaguely related, like a wooded path or a generic stretch of bamboo. You can tell yourself that the path hints at pilgrimage, or that the bamboo stands in for a far off riverbank or a place of learning, but those connections are not immediately clear. In those moments you feel the photograph serving itself rather than serving the line. Or maybe like it's just a placeholder. That said, the photos themselves are rarely less than pleasing to look at. Lopez has a good eye for natural light, color, and texture. The soft blues and pinks of her skies, the glowing petals beaded with raindrops, the mossy roots and stone, all speak to someone who really walks in these places and cares about them. Even when the thematic pairing is loose, the image often still does its job as a visual pause, giving you a moment to breathe before you move to the next line of the poem. The design choice to give each line a full page of its own, paired with a single image, is one of the book’s quiet strengths. The generous white space and the steady rhythm of page turns create a meditative reading experience. You are not skimming a poem on a screen, you are taking a slow walk with it, one phrase and one scene at a time. For readers who already love Emerson, that is a gift. For readers who are new to him, it might be one of the gentlest and most accessible ways to meet his work. From a project standpoint, this feels like a very promising Volume 1. The concept is strong. Pair a classic, spiritually rich poem with contemporary nature photography, use the book format to slow people down, invite them to notice both word and world. With tighter image selection and more deliberate matching in future volumes, this series could become something really special, a kind of ongoing visual conversation with great poets. All in all, this book succeeds more often than it stumbles. The hits are genuinely beautiful and occasionally breathtaking, the misses are mostly matters of redundancy and looseness rather than any lack of skill. If you enjoy contemplative nature photography, classic poetry, or gift books that invite quiet reflection, this is a volume that is well worth sitting with, one line and one photograph at a time. Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Archives
December 2025
Categories |