Editorial Reviews for Nominees
|
|
|
Editorial Reviews for Nominees
|
|
|
|
Score: 88/100 (8.8 out of 10)
Her Wild Body is an unapologetically sensual novel by Noa Raveh. It falls under the category of queer feminist erotic literature. It is an exemplary piece of Sapphic literature. Apparently, it was translated from Hebrew into English. It is structured as a non-linear, multi-voiced exploration of sapphic desire, bodily reclamation, and late-life liberation. Her Wild Body definitely isn't everybody's cup of tea. It certainly wasn't ours. However, it may appeal to readers who are drawn to poetic, emotionally raw, and explicitly sexual narratives centered on intense female desire, exploration, and autonomy. Fans of Jeanette Winterson, Audre Lorde, or Marguerite Duras may appreciate its lyrical intensity and unfiltered intimacy. It’s likely to resonate most with those seeking stories of queer identity, radical self-love, and transformative sensuality—especially told through a deeply personal, stream-of-consciousness lens. The main issue we had with this book is similar to the issue we had with a certain book we read this time last year (A Bright Summer by Kate Smoak): the erotica just doesn't relent, and it's to the point where it becomes redundant, cloying, tedious, and grating. These characters are constantly on top and inside of one another. Apparently, they have jobs and other responsibilities, but you wouldn't know that based on the fact that they're even having sex during work or in between meetings. Like, do these people have nothing else to do? Nothing else to occupy their time or minds? It's just always sex, isn't it? Look, we're not kink shaming, but we are drawing attention to the fact that these characters seems entirely defined by their sexuality. Yes, there's an abortion sub-plot and talk about being Israeli, but it really seems like the dominant thing in this entire book is just having sex as often and as wildly as possible. That doesn't lead to much of a plot. Again, there are attempts at plots like the aforementioned abortion and Israeli discussions, but those are relegated far into the background. They're practically afterthoughts. And it's unfortunate. Like, there's this really humanizing scene in which the narrator encounters a female hedgehog, they have an existential moment, then onto more sex. To be honest, the abortion sub-plot was actually compelling. It had emotional weight, vulnerability, and real-world stakes. It grounded the narrator in something raw and human—something beyond the endless cycle of lust and longing. For a moment, the book pulled back the sheets (pun intended) and offered something deeper: a meditation on loss, choice, identity, and personal rupture. For the first time, we told ourselves: this is a living, breathing human being with actual thoughts, emotions, conflicts, and drama, not some emotionless, robotic sex doll programmed for one function and one function only. But just as quickly, the narrative veered back into more erotica, as if afraid to linger in the discomfort of anything non-sexual. That momentary depth got buried under another tidal wave of orgasms and poetic moaning. Ultimately, the imbalance is what hurt the book for us. Sex is clearly meant to be the vehicle for liberation, identity, and healing—but when it becomes the only vehicle, the story feels emotionally flat and dramatically repetitive. Sensuality without restraint, without contrast, loses its impact. Without real narrative tension or stakes, Her Wild Body begins to feel like a monologue shouted into a mirror: beautifully written, but circling itself endlessly. It's just... too much. It's like perfume or cologne. When you sprit some on, it smells fine, maybe even good. When you drench yourself in it, it becomes cloying. You want to hold your breath and move to a different room from the person. It's like salt or sugar. They taste great in moderation, but when it's dumped onto the food, that's literally all you can taste—either too salty or too sweet. So, this book is so saturated with wild erotic sex that it completely overshadows literally everything else: any characters or plot this book may have had. And yes, this book—believe it or not—had a variety of characters. In fact, most of this book covered the narrator's sexual partners over the years like Noga, Shira, Tammy Gil, Mowgli, Esther Lionheart, and Tom. We're guessing that these aren't intended to be the actual names of these people, more like nicknames. We're guessing this is the case because these characters almost comically or cartoonishly fit the gimmick of their names. Mowgli is often described as being like Tarzan or Jane (alluding to jungle imagery like Mowgli from The Junglebook). Lionheart is often described as being feline or cat-like. It's... poetic. In fact, in all fairness, the poetic prose and writing in this book is rather impressive at times. Here are a few of our favorite passages, many of which make use of techniques like alliteration: "We moan and growl, loud lionesses in the cricket-dotted quiet. We are lone she-wolves, united to run through meadows." "The abortion is over. Four weeks of holocaust in my womb have come to an end." "I want to kick the doctor, yell at him and Tom: Don’t touch my children! Don’t you dare take them! But I remain silent. Instead, tears stream down my face. I grip the brick tighter, desperate to feel anything but my abdomen. I know that relaxing would ease the pain. If I let the children go, it would hurt less, but I can’t. I resist strenuously, contracting around the syringe as if trying to fight it, knowing I have no chance of winning." "She is both the riddle and the answer to questions I never knew I was asking... Painting surrounds her on all sides, flows through her veins. It is her parent, her teacher, her healer. It is solace and knowledge. It is her element and she is painting. They are not truly separate. She serves it and it materializes through her. Her tubes of color are the tools. The paintings—prayer. " "I’d taste the grace of your soft skin, you’d cause an earthquake in me. I’d go up in flames with you, coming to you. I’d be left scorched earth after you." "She exorcises my demons this way, she puts red love in black places. She cooks me like sweet caramel..." "Vitality surges here now. A carnival of senses. The universe itself courses through our veins. We don’t just live in it; it lives in us." Probably our favorite: "We moor, core to core, by the Mediterranean shore." "...you turned me into the Nile Delta. From the farthest reaches of myself, from every nerve ending, in one moment I flowed like a river to the sea.” You know, we actually gave this book a slight ratings boost after reviewing these amazing quotes and passages from it. However, we can get over the fact that we got really bored about half way through this book (for the reasons we described earlier). We would probably give it more credit if there weren't brand new sex scenes listed in the closing pages of the book. Like, if we're looking at this from a literary perspective: you can't be introducing brand new exciting scenes like this when the book is supposed to be winding down. What, are we getting a sequel or something? Why does it seem like this book is still in medes res when it only has a couple of pages left? Anyway, again, this might not be our cup of tea but maybe it's yours. Check it out on Amazon
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Archives
December 2025
Categories |