Outstanding Creator Awards
  • Home
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Testimonials
  • Winners- 2026 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2026 Spring Contest
  • 2025 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- 2025 Clash of Champions
  • Winners- 2025 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2025 Spring Contest
  • 2024 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- 2024 Clash of Champions
  • Winners- 2024 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2024 Creator Classic
  • 2023 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- Clash of Champions 2023
  • Winners- Spring 2023
  • Winners- Winter 2023
  • 2022 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- Fall 2022
  • Winners- Summer 2022
  • Winners- Spring 2022
  • Winners- Winter 2021-2022
  • Terms
  • Privacy Policy

Editorial Reviews for Nominees 
​(May Contain Spoilers and Affiliate Links) 

Review of “Hide the Ash in the Wind” by Tristan Roy Hammack

10/25/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Score: 92/100 (9.2 out of 10)

Hide the Ash in the Wind by Tristan Roy Hammack is an imaginative, emotionally charged, and remarkably unconventional poetry collection that explores identity, vulnerability, human relationships, social expectations, and the complicated business of simply being oneself. Divided into six thematic sections, the collection is an ambitious assortment of experimental poetry, prose poetry, philosophical reflections, dark humor, and allegorical storytelling. Hammack is clearly not a writer who enjoys playing by the rules, and his willingness to experiment with language, presentation, and literary conventions produces some genuinely fascinating results. However, while we admire his creativity and appreciate many of the ideas he explores, we also found ourselves frequently questioning whether his stylistic experimentation was enhancing the poetry or unnecessarily complicating it.

One of the collection's greatest strengths is its examination of the masks people wear to navigate everyday life. Hammack portrays individuals who desperately want meaningful connections with others but are simultaneously terrified of vulnerability, rejection, embarrassment, or simply becoming an inconvenience. In the unusually presented opening poem, "TO_TAKE," the speaker attempts to navigate an overwhelming social interaction through a chaotic mixture of fragmented thoughts, checklists, computer commands, misspellings, and unconventional formatting. What initially appears to be an awkward but potentially heartwarming exchange eventually reveals itself to be something resembling a simulated interaction, giving the poem a fascinating and rather heartbreaking twist.

This is arguably one of the collection's most distinctive pieces, and an excellent example of experimental presentation working in service of its subject matter. Hammack uses the appearance of computer programming, malfunctioning systems, and interrupted commands to represent a mind desperately attempting to process ordinary social interactions. Words appear in unexpected places, sentences become increasingly fragmented, and conventional spelling occasionally gives way to something resembling a malfunctioning thought process. We particularly appreciate how the speaker's emotional distress is communicated not merely through what the words say, but through how they behave on the page. The poem is visually messy, certainly, but in this instance, that messiness feels purposeful.

Indeed, Hammack's willingness to experiment with the physical appearance of poetry is one of his most recognizable characteristics. Rather than limiting himself to conventional stanzas and line breaks, he frequently manipulates spacing, capitalization, typography, and the arrangement of words to influence how readers experience his writing. "Echo's Shadows," for example, employs two parallel columns, allowing visual memories and auditory recollections to develop alongside one another. The resulting arrangement creates something resembling two complementary poems that can be appreciated individually or in relation to each other. We find this especially interesting because the formatting contributes to the poem's exploration of memory, absence, and the different ways people continue to haunt our senses.

Other poems experiment with presentation in considerably more unusual ways. "How We Became Tiny" explicitly instructs readers to speak capitalized words more loudly than lowercase words, effectively turning capitalization into a form of performance direction. This is a clever departure from conventional typography, encouraging readers to consider the sounds and rhythms of the poem rather than simply its appearance. Meanwhile, "e&a breaks" deliberately fragments words and rearranges letters, creating a peculiar reading experience in which language itself appears to be falling apart. Given the poem's references to separation and a breakup, we can appreciate the possibility that the disintegration of words is intended to reflect the disintegration of a relationship. Whether every such experiment succeeds is another matter, but Hammack deserves recognition for exploring how the visual presentation of poetry can become an expressive tool in its own right.

We also appreciate the author's frequent use of alliteration, assonance, rhyme, consonance, and other sound-based literary devices. In "Pain's Worth," for example, the repetition of initial consonant sounds in expressions involving "Danger" and "Drawing," as well as "miasma" and "Maiden," demonstrates his interest in connecting words through their sounds. Elsewhere in the same poem, "Wield words wisely" employs particularly conspicuous alliteration, giving the language a memorable rhythm while reinforcing the importance of communication. In "Metaphors Escape," the phrase "Carry's chrysalis cracks" is another fine example of alliteration, using three successive hard consonant sounds to create a satisfying verbal sequence. Even when the underlying narrative becomes difficult to follow, individual combinations of words can be surprisingly clever.

Assonance and rhyme also contribute to the musicality of certain passages. "The Night's Light," for example, opens with a sequence of short lines emphasizing the recurring long vowel sound in words like "bright," "light," "night," and "sight." Their similarities establish a simple but recognizable rhythm that complements the poem's subject. Elsewhere, Hammack employs internal rhyme, near-rhyme, and playful combinations of words that sound alike but carry different meanings. In "Sheds Left," the progression of "tough," "rough," "bluff," and "enough" provides a particularly noticeable rhythmic pattern, while expressions like "re-leaf" demonstrate the author's enjoyment of manipulating familiar words to create multiple meanings.

Hammack also occasionally experiments with recognizable poetic forms. "Not Sorry Sonnet," for example, follows the fourteen-line structure associated with sonnets and employs a succession of rhymes and near-rhymes to explore the consequences of withholding an apology. Although the meter is not particularly strict, we appreciate the attempt to work within an established poetic tradition while maintaining the author's unconventional voice. The concluding realization that refusing to apologize has cost the speaker a friendship provides an effective emotional payoff, particularly after the preceding verbal playfulness. This demonstrates that Hammack is capable of using traditional structures to support a coherent message rather than simply experimenting for experimentation's sake.

Another interesting technique is his use of repetition, parallelism, contradiction, and rhetorical questions. "Acting Contradiction" repeatedly juxtaposes opposing emotions and circumstances, including the striking contrast between someone appearing at their lowest while standing on a pedestal and at their highest while lying in the gutter. The imagery creates a deliberate contradiction between emotional condition and physical position, reinforcing the poem's central examination of how outward appearances can misrepresent internal experiences. "A Duck in Wolf's Clothing" similarly uses recurring questions about identity, behavior, and personal transformation, building toward the realization that the speaker does not necessarily need an immediate or definitive answer to every question about themselves. Its concluding invitation to discover those answers alongside another person provides a surprisingly hopeful resolution.

We also appreciate the use of irony and paradox in poems like "Just Like You." The speaker attempts to distance themselves from another person, only to recognize that the process of doing so has gradually transformed them into someone remarkably similar to the individual they were trying to avoid. The contradiction is particularly effective because it illustrates how attempts to escape another person's influence can sometimes reinforce that influence instead. This recurring fascination with psychological contradictions helps establish thematic continuity throughout the collection, even when the individual poems differ considerably in style and presentation.

Throughout the collection, Hammack repeatedly questions what society considers normal and how much of ourselves we sacrifice trying to meet those expectations. "A Duck in Wolf's Clothing" explores the exhausting consequences of concealing one's authentic personality beneath a more socially acceptable exterior, while "The Circle Celebration" uses a deceptively simple allegory about children drawing different shapes to examine conformity and intolerance. We particularly appreciate how the latter escalates from an apparently innocent celebration of circles into something considerably more sinister, as an individual becomes convinced that destroying another child's drawings is an act of kindness. The resulting consequences are surprisingly disturbing, illustrating how attempts to protect or correct someone can instead destroy their individuality and enthusiasm.

Another standout is the four-part "Anti Hill Bill" narrative, which develops one of the collection's most memorable and thought-provoking allegories. Bill is a child who desperately wants to climb a hill but continually invents excuses to avoid doing so, convincing himself that the conditions must be perfect before he attempts anything. When Buttons, a classmate who uses a wheelchair, successfully climbs the hill despite considerable difficulties, Bill responds not with admiration but with resentment, eventually convincing himself that hills are inherently undesirable and should be eliminated altogether. His insecurity gradually becomes an ideology that alienates his friends, consumes his identity, and ultimately influences the next generation. We especially appreciate how Hammack demonstrates the transformation of personal fear into bitterness and destructive convictions, illustrating how someone unwilling to confront their own limitations may instead attempt to diminish the accomplishments and opportunities of others.

The "Anti Hill Bill" narrative also raises intriguing questions about opportunities, procrastination, and the consequences of taking things for granted. Early in the story, Bill considers the hill practically immortal, believing it will always be there whenever he finally decides to climb it. The hill becomes something resembling a permanent landmark or foundational pillar, an obstacle that seems to have always existed and will presumably continue existing indefinitely. Its eventual disappearance exposes the fallacy of that assumption, giving the earlier declaration of immortality an ironic significance. We found this particularly interesting because the hill is not merely a physical obstacle; it represents an opportunity Bill repeatedly postpones until that opportunity is no longer available.

The narrative also makes frequent use of playful rhymes, exaggerated language, and alliteration, lending portions of the story an almost nursery-rhyme quality despite its increasingly disturbing subject matter. This contrast between whimsical presentation and darker psychological implications is one of its most interesting qualities. However, the narrative's chronology is not always as clear as it could be, particularly when later installments revisit events surrounding the hill's disappearance after an earlier installment has already described its destruction. Nevertheless, we admire the author's ability to transform such a simple premise into an elaborate examination of fear, resentment, missed opportunities, and the potentially generational consequences of destructive beliefs.

We also appreciate the collection's willingness to approach difficult philosophical questions through straightforward, relatable imagery. One of our favorite passages appears in "Pain's Worth," particularly its "PRICE AND COST" portion, which asks readers to consider whether love is worth the risk, whether games are worth losing, whether adventures are worth injuries, and ultimately whether life is worth dying for. These seemingly simple questions encourage readers to examine the relationship between experience and consequence, and whether knowing the potential costs of our decisions would fundamentally change how we live. The use of parallel sentence structures, repetition, and rhetorical questions creates a compelling rhythm, with each successive comparison building upon the previous one.

What makes this passage especially interesting is the way Hammack subsequently reverses the questions, encouraging readers to reconsider whether unpleasant consequences necessarily diminish the value of otherwise worthwhile experiences. We appreciate the simplicity of the approach because the questions are recognizable, thought-provoking, and surprisingly profound. At its core, the passage asks two fundamental questions: Why do we do what we do, and is what we do worth doing? Sometimes the most straightforward writing has the greatest impact, and we think this passage illustrates that beautifully.

The collection also makes extensive use of imagery and symbolism, frequently transforming familiar objects and experiences into representations of complicated emotional or psychological states. In "Holder's Keeper," the fear of losing loved ones becomes grotesque imagery involving additional hands, death, and an eventual coffin formed from the very hands intended to prevent separation. The macabre imagery is particularly effective because it makes the speaker's emotional desperation appear physically monstrous, transforming a recognizable fear into something disturbing and unforgettable. We admire how the poem communicates the futility of trying to hold on to everything, especially when its increasingly horrifying imagery culminates in the realization that even the most desperate efforts cannot prevent loss.

"Pain's Worth" also contains surprisingly powerful grotesque imagery in its "COMFORTABLE POISON" portion. Hammack combines familiar, comforting experiences with disturbing descriptions of poison, injury, contamination, and physical suffering, creating a contrast between things that feel safe and things that may actually cause harm. The alliterative language helps give certain passages an almost lyrical quality, even as the imagery becomes increasingly repulsive. We found this contrast particularly effective because the writing manages to describe something genuinely disgusting in a strangely compelling and occasionally beautiful way. The juxtaposition of comfort and danger encourages readers to consider how familiar experiences or relationships can be simultaneously reassuring and destructive.

"Just Hate" employs a similarly unsettling approach, using violent, almost cannibalistic or vampiric imagery to portray the lingering psychological consequences of a destructive relationship. We particularly appreciate the opening suggestion of an old echo fermenting over time, an unusual combination of words that makes emotional pain seem as though it has been aging, souring, or intensifying in storage. The association between something old and something fermenting is thematically appropriate, suggesting that past experiences may continue to change and exert influence long after the events themselves have ended. The subsequent descriptions of blood, imprisonment, predatory behavior, and physical suffering give the poem an increasingly oppressive atmosphere. We find the imagery effective, although the sheer intensity of the descriptions occasionally borders on excess.

Elsewhere, the collection's recurring use of fire, water, birds, wolves, and other natural imagery establishes a recognizable symbolic vocabulary. Fire frequently represents passion, attraction, danger, or emotional transformation, while birds often embody freedom, individuality, companionship, and the desire to belong. In "Mountain Brook," the speaker's journey along a mountainside gradually becomes an exploration of attachment, direction, and the consequences of allowing another person or experience to determine one's path. We particularly appreciate how Brook becomes something resembling a named character, with the speaker directly addressing the water as though it possesses an individual identity. The use of personification and direct address becomes especially meaningful near the conclusion, as the brook disappears into the ocean and the speaker wonders whether the familiar entity they once followed still exists somewhere within that enormous body of water.

Another intriguing example is "Garden seeds," which uses a simple agricultural metaphor to explore the consequences of trusting too readily or becoming excessively suspicious. In one scenario, the gardener tends to flowers and weeds indiscriminately, only to discover that the weeds have overtaken everything. In another, fear of cultivating undesirable plants prevents the flowers from receiving the care they need. The underlying message appears to concern the importance of balancing openness with discernment, a concept that fits neatly into the collection's broader examination of relationships and vulnerability. We appreciate the simplicity of the metaphor, although the execution would benefit from somewhat clearer wording.

"WORLD OF FIRE" is particularly noteworthy for its sustained use of an extended metaphor. The speaker inhabits a world seemingly filled with the sparks and flames of passion but struggles to experience the same mysterious phenomenon personally. Through repeated references to fuel, combustion, warmth, and the elusive spark, Hammack explores longing, uncertainty, and the discomfort of feeling different from those around us. The repetition of "spark" at the ends of successive phrases creates an effect resembling epistrophe, continually directing readers back to the one essential element that remains absent. We appreciate that the metaphor also allows for a distinction between different forms of warmth, acknowledging that companionship, family, friendship, and other experiences can provide fulfillment even without the particular spark the speaker initially seeks.

Indeed, one of the collection's more compelling recurring ideas is that meaningful human connection need not conform to society's expectations. "The Lonely Light" and its continuation explore this through an imaginative fable about an independent light ostracized for refusing conventional companionship, only to experience an extraordinary transformation through the collective efforts of others. We particularly appreciate that these stories raise questions not only about the importance of community but also about individuality and the freedom to determine what relationships mean to oneself. There is something especially troubling about a society that effectively criminalizes solitude while claiming to act in the interests of companionship. Hammack's treatment of the subject is more nuanced than simply suggesting that everyone must abandon independence to achieve happiness.

Later, "THE SHOW IS OVER" introduces another fascinating contradiction, as a speaker who has struggled with social masks and artificial identities discovers genuine belonging through theatrical performance. The realization that pretending to be someone else onstage can help someone become more comfortable being themselves is among the collection's most satisfying emotional developments.

We also appreciate how this relates to the earlier poem "I Leave," which follows a speaker through a series of uncomfortable journeys and social encounters. The rugged imagery of mountains, winding roads, fog, and unfamiliar surroundings gives the poem something resembling an adventurous atmosphere, even as the speaker's experiences become increasingly unpleasant. The repeated declaration of leaving eventually gives way to a meaningful reversal when the speaker discovers a community they genuinely enjoy and, for the first time, no longer wants to leave.

We also enjoyed the author's willingness to incorporate humor into an otherwise emotionally heavy collection. "I Kind of Know You," for example, gradually transforms an apparently innocent account of discovering things about another person into a darkly comedic revelation involving a restraining order. Its repeated declarations about what the speaker supposedly did not know create an amusing pattern of escalating revelations, culminating in a punchline that completely reframes the preceding observations. This is a particularly effective use of repetition, irony, and comic timing, demonstrating that Hammack can achieve an entertaining result without requiring an especially elaborate premise. His tendency to manipulate idioms, introduce ridiculous scenarios, and combine incompatible concepts can also be genuinely funny, even when the humor occasionally borders on outright nonsense.

Unfortunately, the same boundless imagination responsible for these memorable moments also contributes to the collection's greatest weaknesses. Hammack frequently experiments with unusual punctuation, capitalization, typography, fragmented language, unconventional spacing, invented words, and increasingly elaborate combinations of metaphors and idioms. While we recognize the artistic intentions behind many of these decisions, the results are not always particularly pleasant to read. "The Blinking Line," for example, presents an interesting concept involving a writing cursor that seemingly assumes control of the creative process, producing an increasingly chaotic assortment of words and absurd imagery. However, the presentation becomes something of an eyesore, and the sheer amount of linguistic nonsense threatens to overwhelm the cleverness of the underlying idea.

"Metaphors Escape" suffers from a similar problem, taking familiar expressions and idioms to increasingly ridiculous extremes until the resulting narrative becomes difficult to follow. We can appreciate the ingenuity required to construct such an elaborate sequence of interconnected puns, but ingenuity alone does not necessarily translate into effective poetry. "The Sad Jester" likewise employs unusual arrangements and fragmented language to illustrate the speaker's emotional defenses, but its presentation can feel unnecessarily messy. There is certainly room for absurdity, deliberate confusion, and unconventional presentation in experimental literature, but these techniques are most successful when they contribute something meaningful to the reading experience. Too often, Hammack's creativity appears to run ahead of his ability to organize, refine, or restrain it.

This is particularly frustrating because Hammack clearly demonstrates familiarity with a variety of literary techniques and possesses the imagination necessary to employ them in unusual ways. However, alliteration, assonance, rhyme, repetition, and wordplay do not automatically improve a passage simply because they are present. Sometimes a clever phrase contributes to the rhythm, reinforces an idea, or creates a memorable image, while other times it seems to exist primarily because the author discovered an amusing combination of words. We would encourage Hammack to be more selective about these devices, ensuring that their presence enhances the poetry rather than drawing attention away from its meaning. A poem does not become more sophisticated simply by becoming more complicated.

We also encountered numerous instances of questionable capitalization, grammatical irregularities, inconsistent punctuation, and awkward sentence construction. Words that would ordinarily remain lowercase are frequently capitalized without any immediately recognizable purpose, as demonstrated by unusual choices in poems like "Quack" and "Pain's Worth." In the latter, words like "Abandoned" and "Last Bit" receive unexpected capitalization, while other potentially significant words do not, making it difficult to determine whether a consistent artistic principle is being followed. Similarly, the philosophical questions in "PRICE AND COST" frequently appear without question marks, despite the occasional inclusion of conventional punctuation elsewhere. We can appreciate the possibility that some of these decisions are intentional, but their inconsistency risks making them appear accidental.

There are also moments when verb tenses or sentence structures become awkward without an obvious artistic justification. The closing lines of "Just Like You," for example, shift between past and present constructions in a manner that could be intentional but nevertheless reads somewhat uncomfortably. Some stylistic irregularities may be deliberate representations of emotional confusion or an unconventional speaking voice, and we certainly would not demand that experimental poetry conform to every convention of formal writing. Nevertheless, there is a meaningful distinction between purposeful artistic experimentation and insufficient editorial refinement, and this collection does not always make that distinction easy to identify. A more meticulous editorial approach could preserve Hammack's unconventional voice while eliminating distractions that make portions of the manuscript appear unnecessarily messy or unfinished.

Another concern is that some poems become so elaborate or abstract that their underlying messages are difficult to decipher, even after considerable reflection. We enjoy poetry that challenges readers to think, reconsider their assumptions, and explore multiple possible interpretations, but excessive obscurity can become a barrier rather than an invitation.

Interestingly, several of the collection's most effective passages, including "The Circle Celebration," "Holder's Keeper," and portions of "Pain's Worth," communicate profound ideas through comparatively simple language and recognizable scenarios. This demonstrates that Hammack does not need to rely on elaborate stylistic gimmicks to produce compelling poetry. In fact, we would argue that greater restraint could make his most inventive experiments considerably more powerful.

The collection's concluding pages offer one final example of its unconventional ambitions. "Where is the Rest of the Poem?" examines how formatting, technology, and reproduction can alter a written work, while the successive versions of "Is Wind Real?" invite readers to consider how a poem evolves through revision. We find the concept intriguing, particularly as the questions shift toward memory, existence, and the impressions people leave behind.

There is something appropriately self-reflective about concluding such an experimental collection by examining the instability of language and the possibility that a poem may never exist in one definitive form. However, presenting multiple versions of the same poem also risks making the conclusion resemble an assortment of unfinished drafts rather than a carefully polished finale.

We would also be remiss not to acknowledge the interesting irony of the collection's title. Ash scattered into the wind cannot truly remain hidden; it disperses, travels, and potentially becomes part of the surrounding environment. The title poem takes this idea to a surprisingly morbid and absurd extreme, imagining a speaker whose remains are scattered through the atmosphere and eventually inhaled by another person. Beyond its dark humor, the imagery offers an unusual way of considering how people leave traces of themselves behind, even after their physical presence has disappeared. This feels especially appropriate for a collection so concerned with memory, relationships, identity, and the lasting consequences of our interactions with others.

Hide the Ash in the Wind is a distinctive and intellectually ambitious poetry collection that offers considerably more than its sometimes chaotic presentation initially suggests. We admire Hammack's imagination, his willingness to explore uncomfortable emotional territory, his unusual sense of humor, and his ability to transform ordinary experiences into imaginative allegories with broader philosophical implications. We also commend his enthusiasm for literary experimentation, particularly his creative employment of alliteration, assonance, rhyme, repetition, wordplay, extended metaphors, visual arrangements, and unconventional poetic structures. While not every experiment succeeds, the collection rarely suffers from a lack of ideas or originality.

We recommend this collection to readers who appreciate experimental literature, unconventional poetry, dark humor, and introspective writing that challenges familiar expectations, provided they are willing to navigate an occasionally bewildering reading experience. At its best, Hammack's writing demonstrates that poetry need not follow a conventional path to reach something meaningful; it simply needs to ensure that readers can still find their way through the wind.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    November 2026
    October 2026
    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

FOLLOW OUR SOCIALS!​

Picture
Picture
Picture
  • Home
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Testimonials
  • Winners- 2026 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2026 Spring Contest
  • 2025 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- 2025 Clash of Champions
  • Winners- 2025 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2025 Spring Contest
  • 2024 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- 2024 Clash of Champions
  • Winners- 2024 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2024 Creator Classic
  • 2023 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- Clash of Champions 2023
  • Winners- Spring 2023
  • Winners- Winter 2023
  • 2022 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- Fall 2022
  • Winners- Summer 2022
  • Winners- Spring 2022
  • Winners- Winter 2021-2022
  • Terms
  • Privacy Policy