Editorial Reviews for Nominees
|
|
|
Editorial Reviews for Nominees
|
|
|
|
Score: 95+/100 (9.5+ out of 10)
This children's book is SPECIAL! And what makes it so special is how layered it is. It's not extremely difficult to score a 9.3 to 9.4 as a children's book in our contests. All you really need are some above-average illustrations, decent writing, decent characters, and a decent premise. But what the best children's books in our contests do is go above and beyond: they develop characters, they tell layered/multi-dimensional stories that grip and resonate with readers without being borish or overwhelming (remember: young people tend to have short attention spans). That's how you score in the coveted 9.5 to 9.6 range like The Adventures of Belle Bear by Kathy Akopov Guillory. So, let's peel back the layers of this exceptional children's book! The Adventures of Belle Bear follows the journey of Belle Bear and her family from Mount Bearia (a stand in for either Russia or colder-climate US states like Washington) to a strange new land called Calibearia (a stand in for California). How will Belle Bear adapt to the hotter, sunnier weather? Will she find new friends? Will she still be able to hold onto the parts of Belle that make her... well... Belle? Or will the heat become oppressive? Will she be ostracized and not fit in? Will she be forced to abandon who she was (and is), the things she loved, and to become more like everyone else to survive in this strange new world? It's the story of an immigrant, yes. But it's also the story of childhood and the experience of living in general. Few people stay in the same place doing the same things all their lives. Childhood and life are full of changes and transitions. These can be scary. They include things like parents getting divorced, a parent losing or getting a new job, deployment, moving schools, moving cities, etc. Those experiences can be traumatic and nerve-racking for kids, causing anxiety and uncertainty. Stability and familiarity are often shaken and shattered by these dramatic life events. You don't have to be an immigrant to relate with Belle Bear. You could just be human—someone who has had to leave familiar things, people, and places behind. And that resonated with us. On the surface, it is a simple story: Belle Bear lives a happy, snowy life in Mount Bearia with her super-supportive grandmother, Baba Bear. When they have to move to hot, crowded Calibearia, Belle feels out of place, different from everyone else, and lonely at school. With Baba Bear’s help and the “you are kind, you are curious, you are brave” mantra, she rediscovers her confidence, gets a new orange cape, and starts making friends who love hearing about her old home. One of the things that will stand out to readers is the relationship between Belle and Baba Bear, who is sure to remind kids of a parent or grandparent in their lives. The repeated bedtime affirmation and the way Baba Bear notices something is wrong without pushing too hard feel very emotionally true. The mirror scene, where Belle says who she is and the new cape appears, is a beautiful way to show kids that confidence comes from remembering their strengths, not from outside approval. The art really supports that: the warm glow of their hut, the big mirror, and the cape appearing on Belle’s shoulders make it feel magical and safe at the same time. The cape isn't some meaningless, superficial thing either. The cape represents identity. It represents an article of clothing or an accessory that helps to distinguish one person (or persons) from others. It's part of what makes Belle Belle, and it seems to be part of a tradition and a culture given that Baba Bear also wears a cape. Maybe you and your family have things that set you apart: a hairstyle, an heirloom, an article of clothing, a favorite saying, a blanket, a food, a holiday tradition. Belle's cape captures all of that in one simple, visual way that kids can immediately understand. It is something she literally wears on her shoulders that reminds her who she is and where she comes from, even when everything around her has changed. That ties beautifully into one of the strongest aspects of this book: the use of simple, repeated language to build self-esteem. The "you are kind, you are curious, you are brave" mantra is incredibly effective. It is short, memorable, and specific. It does not just say "you are special." It points to qualities that kids can practice and live out. You can easily imagine a parent or teacher borrowing those exact words and using them as a daily affirmation with their own children or students. We also love that this is not just a story about "being yourself" in a vacuum. Belle is not magically fine the moment she arrives in Calibearia. The book takes time to show that she struggles. She is lonely. She feels different. The sun is too hot. The beach is too crowded. No one looks like her. Those pages validate the uncomfortable feelings that come with a big move or a major life change. Kids are allowed to feel sad, scared, and unsure before they feel brave. Once Belle "remembers" herself in the mirror and puts on the new orange cape, the story shifts into a beautiful demonstration of how sharing your story can turn differences into strengths. Belle does not win people over by pretending to be like everyone else. She wins them over by talking about Mount Bearia, the snow, the igloos, the chess boards, and the cool, cozy world she left behind. Her classmates lean in. They ask questions. They want to know more. The very things that made Belle feel odd and alone become the things that make her interesting and magnetic. The immigrant metaphor is handled in a way that works on multiple levels. For kids who have moved from one city or state to another, it will feel familiar and comforting. For kids who have immigrated from another country or culture, the story may feel deeply personal. And for kids who have never moved at all, it becomes a gentle window into what their classmates might be going through. Without ever lecturing, the book encourages empathy. It quietly suggests that the "new kid" in class may be carrying a whole world of memories, traditions, and feelings on their shoulders, just like Belle's cape. The illustrations deserve a lot of credit for how well this all lands. The snowy blues and cozy lamplight of Mount Bearia contrast beautifully with the bright yellows and sandy tones of Calibearia. You can feel the temperature change with your eyes. There are fun, thoughtful details sprinkled on almost every page: the polar bear chess board, the warm and inviting interior of Baba Bear's home, the little backpacks and lunchboxes, the waves, and the variety of animals in Belle's new school. It is the kind of book that rewards slow page turns and repeated readings. Kids will keep spotting new things, and adults will not get bored rereading it. Seriously, some of these characters in the illustrations are genuinely cute. There's a giraffe in here named Ginny who is one of the cutest characters we've seen in a while—big eyes, stylish hair, and long eyelashes. We also really like the interactive touch at the end with the question, "What color is your cape?" and the mention of coloring pages. That simple prompt invites children to step into the story and see themselves as brave, kind, and curious in their own unique way. It is exactly the kind of extension activity that parents, teachers, and counselors can build on. You can imagine a whole classroom drawing their own "capes" and sharing what makes them who they are. Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Archives
April 2026
Categories |