Editorial Reviews for Nominees
|
|
|
Editorial Reviews for Nominees
|
|
|
|
Score: 92/100 (9.2 out of 10)
Through Scotty's Eyes is a heartwarming, insightful, and educational children's book by Cal Davis that offers readers a glimpse into the world of a young boy with autism. Through colorful illustrations, simple narration, and relatable everyday experiences, the author helps readers better understand some of the behaviors, challenges, and unique perspectives associated with autism. This is a book with a big heart and an even bigger purpose, and we appreciate what the author is trying to accomplish! The story follows Scotty, an adorable six-year-old boy who lives with his mother, father, and baby brother, affectionately referred to as Bubby. Throughout the book, readers accompany Scotty as he goes about his daily life, whether he's playing with his toys, spending time with his family, attending school, or visiting different places. Along the way, we discover that Scotty experiences the world a little differently from some of the people around him. He enjoys arranging his blocks in straight lines, moving his hands, spinning around, watching the same things repeatedly, and engaging in familiar routines that provide him with comfort and reassurance. We also witness some of the challenges Scotty experiences. Changes in routine can be upsetting, certain situations can become overwhelming, and seemingly ordinary experiences can provoke intense emotional reactions. For example, there's a particularly memorable sequence in which Scotty and his family attend a fireworks display. While many children might find the colorful explosions exciting, Scotty becomes frightened by the loud noises and bright lights. He covers his ears, becomes distressed, and ultimately needs to leave. This is a simple but effective illustration of how an experience that seems perfectly enjoyable to one person can be deeply uncomfortable or overwhelming to another. The real winning ingredient here, however, is the book's educational purpose. While the story itself is sweet and accessible, its greatest accomplishment is helping readers understand some of the reasons behind Scotty's behaviors. Rather than simply showing a child engaging in repetitive movements, becoming upset, or struggling with unexpected changes, the author provides additional context that can help readers understand what Scotty might be experiencing. We particularly love the book's Autism Characteristics section at the end, which provides 25 individual explanations corresponding to the 25 illustrated story pages. This is honestly one of our favorite features of the entire book! Each explanation helps readers recognize how a seemingly ordinary moment in Scotty's life can represent or exemplify a particular aspect of autism. For example, Scotty's enjoyment of jumping and walking on his toes introduces readers to stimming and sensory regulation, while his preference for arranging blocks in straight lines illustrates how repetition and order can provide comfort. His teacher's use of pictures and sign language demonstrates alternative methods of communication and the importance of preparing children for transitions. His attachment to chicken nuggets introduces the subject of food preferences and sensory sensitivities, while his frightening experience with fireworks illustrates sensory overload. Even his enjoyment of swinging and his family's efforts to comfort him offer opportunities to discuss self-regulation and emotional support. We appreciate how these explanations help connect the dots between what readers see happening in the story and what those experiences might mean. They're not simply repeating what happened on each page; they're providing additional context, insight, and practical knowledge that readers can carry into their own lives. This transforms the book from an adorable children's story into something considerably more useful. Parents, teachers, caregivers, and children can read the story for enjoyment and then consult the corresponding explanations to develop a deeper understanding of the behaviors and experiences being portrayed. We think that's a fantastic approach! Another thing we particularly appreciate is that this book doesn't try to reinvent the wheel or become some exhaustive encyclopedia of autism. That's not its purpose, nor does it need to be. Instead, it seeks to simply, succinctly, and effectively raise awareness, promote understanding, and educate readers about autism, particularly those who may have little firsthand experience with it. At the same time, it offers valuable insights for people with autism and the families, friends, teachers, and caregivers who share their lives. We appreciate that the author doesn't unnecessarily complicate the subject or overwhelm readers with mountains of information. He keeps things approachable, relatable, and easy to understand, which is precisely what makes the book such a worthwhile educational resource. Furthermore, we appreciate that the book emphasizes the importance of patience, understanding, compassion, and accommodating individual needs. Scotty's parents and teacher make efforts to understand him and help him navigate the world around him. For example, his teacher, Miss Nonna (who is super cute, in a Disney-princess-sorta-way and a likely candidate for Cutest Character), uses pictures and sign language to communicate and help him understand what to expect. At home, Scotty finds comfort in his swing chair, familiar routines, and the reassuring presence of his family. These details help demonstrate that supporting a child with autism isn't necessarily about forcing that child to behave like everyone else. Sometimes, it's about recognizing what makes that child comfortable, understanding their needs, and meeting them where they are. We've had the pleasure of reviewing Cal Davis's work before, including his exciting science-fiction novel The Mines of Jedira, which previously won an Outstanding Creator Award. That book impressed us with its imaginative world-building, exciting adventures, and engaging storytelling. Through Scotty's Eyes is obviously a very different undertaking, but it's interesting to see the author applying his writing abilities to something so personal and educational. Indeed, the author's biography reveals that he has firsthand experience helping raise two grandsons with autism, and we believe that personal connection adds another dimension of sincerity and emotional significance to this book. As for the illustrations, they're quite good! The colorful digital artwork is attractive, expressive, and generally well suited to the intended audience. Scotty is an adorable little character, and we appreciate the care taken to maintain consistency in the appearances of the recurring characters. Their clothing also changes throughout the book, as it naturally should when different days and situations are depicted. The various environments, from Scotty's bedroom and classroom to the family home and outdoor settings, are detailed and inviting. The illustrations help establish a warm, welcoming atmosphere that complements the educational material. Another thing we find interesting and commendable is the portrayal of Scotty's parents as a multiracial couple raising their children together. We appreciate seeing this kind of representation in a work of children's fiction, especially because the book doesn't go out of its way to draw attention to their racial differences or make them the subject of the story. They're simply a loving mother and father doing their best to raise and support their children. It's a welcome depiction of a family, and it reinforces the book's larger message about understanding, acceptance, and love. In a book that encourages readers to appreciate differences rather than judge people by them, this feels particularly fitting. We do, however, have a reservation about the illustrations, and it's something we've encountered in other children's books, including Best Dad Ever—No Take Backs! and 8 Steps to Becoming an Entrepreneur for Kids. Sometimes, the characters seem to be looking straight ahead, almost toward the reader, when they should naturally be looking at another character or an object beside them. For example, there are scenes in which characters are supposedly watching television, interacting with one another, or responding to something happening around them, yet their gazes don't always convincingly match the action. It actually reminds us of the hilarious Bret Hart wrestling meme, which pokes fun at the unnatural way professional wrestlers sometimes watch matches on backstage television monitors. Instead of facing the screen like a normal person, they're standing at some bizarre angle, seemingly more concerned with making sure the camera gets a good shot of their faces than actually watching what's happening! That's sometimes the impression we get from the illustrations in this book. We understand why artists might want to showcase their characters' faces, but sometimes it makes the illustrations feel more like posed photographs than spontaneous moments captured from everyday life. This isn't a major problem, but it is noticeable enough to occasionally detract from the otherwise solid presentation. Through Scotty's Eyes is a thoughtful, compassionate, and worthwhile children's book that succeeds most where it matters: helping readers develop a greater understanding of autism and the people who experience it. It's not the most elaborate or sophisticated children's story we've encountered, nor is it trying to be. Its strength lies in its simplicity, accessibility, and sincere desire to educate. We especially appreciate how the story and its accompanying explanations complement one another, making the lessons more memorable and meaningful than they might have been if presented separately. Scotty may experience the world differently, but like any other child, he wants to feel safe, happy, accepted, and loved. That's a message worth sharing, and we're happy to recommend this book to families, educators, caregivers, and anyone interested in developing a better understanding of autism! Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Archives
November 2026
Categories |