Outstanding Creator Awards
  • Home
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Testimonials
  • Winners- 2026 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2026 Spring Contest
  • 2025 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- 2025 Clash of Champions
  • Winners- 2025 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2025 Spring Contest
  • 2024 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- 2024 Clash of Champions
  • Winners- 2024 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2024 Creator Classic
  • 2023 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- Clash of Champions 2023
  • Winners- Spring 2023
  • Winners- Winter 2023
  • 2022 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- Fall 2022
  • Winners- Summer 2022
  • Winners- Spring 2022
  • Winners- Winter 2021-2022
  • Terms
  • Privacy Policy

Editorial Reviews for Nominees 
​(May Contain Spoilers and Affiliate Links) 

Review of “Oh Little One, Who Will You Be?” by Sharon Varney, Illustrated by Anthony Richichi

11/10/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Score: 95/100 (9.5 out of 10)

This Halloween, our newborn daughter dressed as a doctor. She's only a few months old, yet we've already caught ourselves imagining her growing up to become a physician, saving lives and helping people in need. We've also dreamed of seeing her become an Olympic gold medalist in gymnastics, standing atop the podium with a medal around her neck and the whole world watching. These are admittedly lofty ambitions for someone who hasn't even learned to walk yet! But that's one of the wonderful, exciting, and occasionally amusing things about becoming a parent: suddenly, you're looking at this tiny human being and imagining all the extraordinary things they might accomplish someday. That's precisely the feeling Sharon Varney captures so beautifully in Oh Little One, Who Will You Be?

We've had the pleasure of reviewing this book before, but returning to it as new parents ourselves has given us an even deeper appreciation for its message. There's something incredibly powerful about holding your baby in your arms, looking into their little eyes, and realizing that an entire lifetime of experiences, discoveries, relationships, and accomplishments lies ahead of them. Who will they become? What will they love? What talents and passions will they discover? What impact will they have on the world? Varney explores these questions through a colorful collection of childhood experiences that hint at the incredible possibilities waiting just beyond the horizon.

What's especially appealing about this book is the relationship between the ordinary and the extraordinary. Varney and illustrator Anthony Richichi repeatedly show children engaging in familiar activities before introducing the exciting possibilities those interests might represent. One particularly effective sequence features a baby lying in a crib beneath a colorful mobile of planets before the illustration transitions into an astronaut floating through the cosmos. Another depicts a child playing with cardboard boxes before transitioning into a breathtaking cityscape, suggesting that today's playful little builder might someday help construct the skyscrapers of tomorrow. We love the idea that something seemingly insignificant, like a child's fascination with building blocks, animals, or music, might eventually develop into a lifelong passion or even a remarkable career.

We particularly appreciate the book's understanding that a child's potential extends beyond professional accomplishments. Consider the young boy tending to another child's injury, followed by an illustration of someone protecting a younger child from the rain. The accompanying verse associates nursing with tenderness, compassion, and the ability to soothe suffering. It's a lovely reminder that the qualities we admire in adults often begin developing long before anyone chooses a profession. Curiosity, empathy, patience, and enthusiasm are already valuable characteristics, regardless of where they eventually lead.

Anthony Richichi, OCA's co-recipient of the 2023 Artist of the Year award, brings considerable imagination and energy to these scenes. The artwork shifts effortlessly between everyday environments and elaborate flights of fancy, including outer space, sprawling natural landscapes, laboratories, and bustling musical performances. We also enjoyed the recurring presence of butterflies, flowers, sunshine, and other natural details that give the book a cheerful, almost storybook-fantasy atmosphere. There's something especially charming about the contrast between the simplicity of a child's actions and the grand scale of what those actions might someday become. Richichi's illustrations communicate this wonderfully, often conveying an entire idea before the reader even begins examining the accompanying text.

The writing itself is intentionally simple, with short, rhyming verses designed for young audiences. Some passages flow more smoothly than others, and certain career possibilities receive relatively little explanation, but the book's brevity is also part of its accessibility. The recurring question provides a familiar rhythm that younger children can anticipate, while the illustrations offer opportunities to stop and discuss what they're seeing. We can easily imagine children pointing excitedly at different scenes, identifying their favorite activities, and announcing all the things they'd like to try someday. In that respect, the book could be particularly effective as an interactive reading experience rather than something to rush through from beginning to end.

One of the most meaningful realizations we've had as new parents is just how naturally these enormous dreams develop. You want your child to be happy, healthy, successful, and fulfilled, and your imagination sometimes runs wild with the possibilities. Perhaps she'll become a brilliant doctor, a celebrated athlete, a talented artist, or something we haven't even considered yet. Of course, our daughter will eventually develop her own interests and ambitions, and whatever path she chooses will be hers to discover. We think that's an important part of what makes this book so touching. It's perfectly natural for parents to dream big for their children, but there's also something beautiful about watching those children gradually discover their own dreams.

The final illustration is a fitting way to conclude the experience. A young girl enthusiastically pursues butterflies along a winding path beneath a beautiful, colorful sky, with the surrounding landscape stretching into the distance. It's a wonderfully simple image, yet it captures the book's central idea: there is so much to discover, so much to experience, and so much of life's journey still ahead. The child doesn't need to know exactly where that path will take her. For now, there's a whole world waiting to be explored!

Oh Little One, Who Will You Be? is a heartwarming celebration of childhood, imagination, parenthood, and the limitless potential of the future. Its imaginative illustrations, accessible poetry, and uplifting message make it an enjoyable choice for parents, teachers, and caregivers, particularly those who find themselves marveling at what their little ones might someday become. Having recently welcomed a child into our own family, we can attest to just how deeply this book's message resonates. There is something almost overwhelming about looking at a newborn baby and recognizing how much possibility exists within someone so small. Whether our daughter becomes a doctor, an Olympic champion, or something entirely different, we can't wait to discover who she'll become. And we suspect countless other parents will feel exactly the same way.

Check it out on Amazon!

0 Comments

Review of "The Littlest Pelican: Part 1" by Susan Marie Chapman, illustrated by Natalia Loseva

11/9/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Score: 93/100 (9.3 out of 10)

Legacy.

It's something that matters tremendously to a lot of us. We go through life wanting to make our parents and grandparents proud, hoping to honor their accomplishments, carry on their traditions, and perhaps achieve something extraordinary that would make all their sacrifices worthwhile. We want to make something of ourselves, partly for our own sake, but also for the people who came before us. Sometimes, we even feel an enormous responsibility to live up to the family name, especially when our parents or grandparents have accomplished something remarkable.

Of course, there's another side to this dynamic. Parents and grandparents often have tremendous hopes and dreams for their children and grandchildren. As we explored in our review of Sharon Varney's delightful children's book "Oh Little One, Who Will You Be?", there's something truly wonderful about imagining what the next generation might accomplish. Will they become great athletes? Brilliant scientists? Successful artists? Extraordinary leaders? Perhaps they'll achieve something we never could, fulfilling dreams that we've spent our own lives pursuing or paving the way for. We want them to succeed, to become something great, and to make us proud.

But what happens when those dreams become expectations? What happens when a child desperately wants to honor a family legacy but struggles to live up to it? And perhaps most importantly, what happens when that child begins to believe that failure means disappointing the people they love?

These are some of the surprisingly poignant questions at the heart of Susan Marie Chapman's charming and heartfelt children's book, The Littlest Pelican Part 1, an uplifting story about family, perseverance, self-confidence, and the importance of unconditional love.

The story takes place along the beautiful Gulf of Mexico/Gulf of America, where an ambitious young pelican dreams of joining the prestigious Pelican Squad. This isn't just some ordinary team, either! His grandfather served as its captain for many years, and the little bird hopes to follow in his footsteps and carry on the family legacy. Unfortunately, the Littlest Pelican has already experienced considerable hardship in his young life, having lost his father under mysterious circumstances when he was still a baby. His grandfather has subsequently become his guardian, mentor, and greatest supporter, regularly reminding him that he is "small but mighty." It's a touching relationship that provides the emotional foundation for the entire story.

When the highly competitive Pelican Squad tryouts finally begin, the Littlest Pelican is determined to prove himself. With his grandfather's lessons firmly in mind, he takes to the sky, spots a school of anchovies, and prepares to execute the perfect dive. The illustrations build anticipation as he soars above the water, plunges toward his target, and emerges with his enormous bill seemingly filled with fish. Unfortunately, when the coach asks him to reveal his catch, there's nothing inside except seawater! It's a devastating moment, made considerably worse when the other pelicans begin laughing, pointing, and making cruel remarks about his abilities.

This is where the story becomes particularly relatable. Most of us have experienced the humiliation of failing at something important, especially when surrounded by people who seem eager to celebrate our misfortunes. Children, in particular, can be tremendously sensitive to criticism, ridicule, and feelings of inadequacy. Chapman captures these emotions effectively, especially when the Littlest Pelican retreats behind a dock piling to cry. His subsequent apology to his grandfather, in which he expresses his fear of being a disappointment, is arguably the most heartbreaking moment in the entire book.

And this is where the story's exploration of legacy becomes especially meaningful. The Littlest Pelican wants so desperately to follow in his grandfather's footsteps that he begins to associate his own worth with his ability to accomplish that goal. He doesn't simply feel that he's failed a competition; he feels that he's failed someone who means the world to him. It's a powerful distinction, and one that many children and adults alike will undoubtedly understand.

Fortunately, the Littlest Pelican isn't alone. His grandfather, Grumpy the Iguana, and the Green Parrot are all there to encourage him, reminding him that his journey is far from over. We particularly appreciate how his grandfather handles the situation, assuring the young bird that he has always brought tremendous joy and happiness into his life. He also points out that none of the competing pelicans performed perfectly and that the competition isn't decided by a single accomplishment. It's an important lesson about maintaining perspective, refusing to become discouraged by setbacks, and understanding that our worth extends far beyond our achievements.

Another highlight is Natalia Loseva's colorful, playful artwork, which gives the story a distinctive visual personality. The illustrations have a charming, hand-drawn quality, featuring expressive animal characters, vibrant coastal scenery, and amusing exaggerations. We especially enjoyed the illustration of Grandpa Pelican as an enormous, muscular superhero-like figure, reinforcing the idea that his grandson is "small but mighty." The pictures depicting the other pelicans pointing and laughing are also surprisingly effective, visually emphasizing how isolated and vulnerable the little bird feels. Meanwhile, the exaggerated expressions of Grumpy and the Green Parrot provide welcome moments of humor and personality.

That said, the illustrations occasionally struggle with character differentiation. Because of the relatively simple, uniform art style, some of the characters tend to blend together visually, becoming difficult to distinguish from one another. This is particularly noticeable among the pelicans, many of whom share nearly identical appearances, with the most obvious exception being the Littlest Pelican himself, who is, well, the littlest! While the simplicity of the designs contributes to the book's playful, approachable aesthetic, a little more visual variety among the characters would have helped establish their individual identities and made certain scenes easier to follow. Nevertheless, the artwork remains colorful, expressive, and well-suited to the story's intended audience.

The writing is straightforward and accessible, making this an enjoyable book for young children and families to read together. Nevertheless, Chapman isn't afraid to explore some surprisingly serious subjects, including bereavement, bullying, disappointment, and the pressure of living up to family expectations. The story's simplicity generally works in its favor, allowing these themes to emerge naturally without overwhelming younger readers. We do think the narrative occasionally moves rather quickly through its more emotional developments, particularly the mysterious circumstances surrounding the Littlest Pelican's father, which introduce an intriguing subplot that remains unexplored in this installment.

It's also worth emphasizing that this is explicitly the first part of a larger adventure, and this is where we have one of our biggest reservations about the book. We understand that, in real life, achieving our dreams rarely comes with instant gratification. The road to success is often filled with obstacles, disappointments, setbacks, and moments when we question whether we should continue pursuing our goals at all. However, we're not entirely convinced that this was the right story to leave readers on a cliffhanger.

After spending nearly fifty pages following the Littlest Pelican's ambitions, preparations, disastrous performance, and subsequent emotional struggles, we wanted to see his journey reach a more satisfying conclusion. One could certainly argue that the real payoff comes when his grandfather reassures him that he's loved and appreciated regardless of his performance, and there's considerable merit to that interpretation. It's a beautiful lesson, and perhaps the most important one in the book. Nevertheless, with a children's story of this length, we feel that readers deserve a more complete narrative journey, particularly after investing so much time and emotion in the protagonist's dream. We want to see our characters progress from A to Z, rather than A to H, only to be told that we'll have to pick up another book to discover what happens next. Kids don't usually have the patience or attention spans for that.

Indeed, the story ends just as the Littlest Pelican is preparing to put everything he's learned into practice, leaving the central conflict unresolved. We would've loved to see him take that final dive, regardless of whether he ultimately made the squad. Even an unsuccessful second attempt could've provided a satisfying conclusion if it demonstrated meaningful growth, resilience, and renewed confidence. Instead, the story concludes before readers can witness that development, making this installment feel somewhat incomplete despite its genuinely touching emotional message.

With that said, this book is still solid overall with a lot to teach young readers. We particularly enjoyed the closing sequence, in which the characters gather together, lock their wings and arms, and recite a series of encouraging affirmations:

"You are brave!
You are strong!
You are confident!
You are unstoppable!
And most of all, you are loved, little pelican."

It's a beautiful sentiment, and that final reminder of unconditional love is what makes the passage so meaningful. In many ways, it brings us right back to the idea of legacy and the hopes that parents and grandparents have for the generations that follow. Of course we want our children and grandchildren to accomplish wonderful things. Of course we want them to succeed, make us proud, and perhaps even surpass our own achievements. But we should never allow those hopes and dreams to overshadow something infinitely more important: making sure our children know that they are loved and valued regardless of what they accomplish. There will always be challenges to overcome, mistakes to learn from, and people who doubt our capabilities. Yet having someone who believes in us, especially when we're struggling to believe in ourselves, can make an extraordinary difference.

The Littlest Pelican Part 1 is an uplifting, endearing, and emotionally resonant children's book about perseverance, self-confidence, family, and friendship. Susan Marie Chapman has created an appealing young protagonist whose struggles are easy to understand and whose determination makes him someone readers will naturally want to cheer for. Combined with Natalia Loseva's delightful illustrations and the story's encouraging message, this is a worthwhile addition to a young reader's bookshelf. We look forward to discovering whether the Littlest Pelican can overcome his disappointing first performance and fulfill his dream of joining the Pelican Squad!

After all, he might be the littlest pelican, but there's nothing little about his dreams!

Check it out on Amazon!


0 Comments

Review of “50 Forgotten Cardinals” by Will Saulsbery

11/8/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Score: 93+/100 (9.3+ out of 10)

Baseball is a sport built upon history, tradition, statistics, and the extraordinary accomplishments of generations of athletes. When discussing the St. Louis Cardinals, legendary names such as Stan Musial, Bob Gibson, Lou Brock, Ozzie Smith, and Albert Pujols naturally dominate the conversation. However, countless other players have contributed to the franchise's remarkable history, sometimes achieving greatness without receiving the recognition they deserve. In 50 Forgotten Cardinals, Will Saulsbery sets out to celebrate fifty of these players, delivering an entertaining, informative, and frequently hilarious tribute to baseball's overlooked heroes.

Saulsbery approaches his subject with the enthusiasm of a lifelong fan and the curiosity of a dedicated historian. His personal connection to the Cardinals is immediately apparent, particularly in his affectionate recollections of watching baseball in his grandmother's living room and developing an enduring admiration for Ray Lankford. The book also features a foreword by legendary Cardinals manager Tony La Russa, who playfully challenges the premise that Cardinals fans ever truly forget their players. This distinction between forgetting and remembering becomes one of the book's most appealing underlying themes, as Saulsbery reminds readers that remarkable achievements deserve recognition regardless of how many decades have passed.

Organized chronologically across different eras of Cardinals history, the book introduces readers to fifty fascinating individuals, beginning with the wonderfully named Ice Box Chamberlain and concluding with Aledmys Díaz. Each player receives a compact profile featuring a photograph, biographical information, relevant statistics, and an account of his accomplishments and personal experiences. Saulsbery's selections are deliberately subjective, incorporating accomplished players, former All-Stars, fascinating personalities, and even individuals whose brief appearances in St. Louis might otherwise have escaped notice. This flexibility allows the author to explore baseball history from an enjoyably unconventional perspective, where an unforgettable nickname or extraordinary personal story can be every bit as deserving of attention as a championship ring.

Among the book's greatest strengths is Saulsbery's ability to make historical statistics feel exciting and relevant. Bob Caruthers' astonishing 1885 season, during which he won forty games while compiling a 2.07 ERA, becomes especially remarkable when considered alongside modern pitching workloads.

Similarly, Harry Brecheen's magnificent World Series performances, Dick Groat's accomplishments in both professional baseball and basketball, and Bob Tewksbury's exceptional command of the strike zone provide compelling reminders of how many extraordinary athletes have been overshadowed by more celebrated contemporaries. Saulsbery frequently compares players across generations, encouraging readers to reconsider their assumptions about what constitutes greatness. His enthusiasm occasionally becomes hyperbolic, but the underlying appreciation for these players is sincere and infectious.


Some of the book's finest moments emerge when the author explores the human experiences behind the athletic accomplishments. Austin McHenry's heartbreaking death from a brain tumor at twenty-seven represents a devastating example of unfulfilled potential, while Whitey Kurowski's accomplishments despite a severely damaged throwing arm demonstrate remarkable perseverance. Particularly meaningful is the profile of Tom Alston, the first Black player to appear for the Cardinals, whose experiences with racial prejudice, psychological difficulties, and eventual recognition by the organization add considerable emotional depth to the collection.

Saulsbery also provides a thoughtful reassessment of Ernie Broglio, a talented pitcher whose reputation has become almost inseparable from the famously lopsided trade that brought Lou Brock to St. Louis. These stories remind readers that baseball history encompasses human suffering, resilience, injustice, and dignity alongside championships and individual accomplishments.



Interestingly, this book reminded us of Patrick Montgomery's The Baseball Miracle of the Splendid 6 and Towny Townsend, another excellent baseball history book we reviewed several years ago and awarded 93+/100. Both books recognize something that is sometimes overlooked in sports literature: the accomplishments that make athletes remarkable extend beyond their statistics, championships, and individual accolades. Montgomery's book emphasizes the extraordinary influence of Coach Towny Townsend, his dedication to developing young athletes, and the accomplishments of six players whose contributions to baseball and their communities deserve greater recognition.

Saulsbery takes a broader historical approach, introducing readers to fifty individuals whose stories might otherwise be overshadowed by the celebrated legends of the Cardinals franchise. What we particularly appreciate about both works is their recognition that behind those baseball cards, uniforms, and numbers in the record books are human beings with families, ambitions, struggles, personalities, and lives that extend beyond the ballpark.

There is also an interesting difference in how these two authors approach their subjects. Montgomery's work is particularly concerned with character, mentorship, perseverance, and the positive influence that athletes and coaches can have on society. Saulsbery places greater emphasis on historical accomplishments, statistical comparisons, nostalgia, and humor, making his book feel like an enthusiastic conversation with a knowledgeable baseball fan. Where Montgomery often seeks to inspire readers through the extraordinary personal journeys of his subjects,

Saulsbery frequently seeks to surprise and entertain them with forgotten achievements, bizarre circumstances, and colorful personalities. Both approaches have considerable merit, and we appreciate how they demonstrate that sports nonfiction can be informative, emotionally meaningful, and entertaining even for audiences who do not ordinarily follow baseball.

Humor is another defining characteristic of Saulsbery's writing, and he clearly enjoys entertaining his audience. His fascination with colorful names such as Vinegar Bend Mizell, Bugs Raymond, Ripper Collins, and Homer "Doc" Smoot produces numerous amusing observations and unexpected cultural comparisons. Glenn Brummer's improbable steal of home plate in 1982 is recounted with the excitement of someone watching the play unfold in real time, while Edward Mujica's wonderfully peculiar bullpen superstitions provide another memorable diversion.

The author's conversational style, occasional profanity, playful exaggerations, and unabashed Cardinals loyalty create the atmosphere of an enthusiastic discussion among friends at the ballpark. Although some readers may find the recurring superlatives and informal expressions excessive, they establish a recognizable voice that distinguishes the book from more conventional sports histories.

The presentation is practical and accessible, with historical photographs, baseball cards, statistical summaries, references, and an index complementing the individual profiles. Readers can explore the book chronologically or enjoy particular entries independently, making it suitable for casual reading and repeated visits. The closing selections of an all-time forgotten Cardinals lineup, pitching staff, and amusingly named players provide a fitting conclusion to the author's celebration of the franchise. Nevertheless, the manuscript would benefit from additional editorial refinement, as scattered typographical errors, occasional inconsistencies in statistical information, and uneven formatting detract somewhat from its professionalism. Some profiles also feel considerably more developed than others, and the author's repeated reliance on emphatic praise occasionally diminishes the impact of accomplishments that are already impressive enough to speak for themselves.

One could also argue that the book's appeal is somewhat limited by its narrow focus on a single baseball franchise, particularly given the author's enthusiastic use of statistics and references that casual readers might not immediately appreciate. However, we would encourage readers unfamiliar with the Cardinals to give this book a chance, because some of its most interesting stories concern universal human experiences such as overcoming adversity, confronting illness, pursuing one's dreams, and coping with disappointment. Indeed, as we discovered when reviewing Montgomery's aforementioned book, sports literature can be surprisingly engaging even for those who have little interest in the sport itself. There is something inherently fascinating about discovering an extraordinary individual whose accomplishments have largely faded from public memory, particularly when that individual's life contains enough drama, tragedy, or humor to rival the most imaginative works of fiction.

50 Forgotten Cardinals succeeds admirably in its central mission of preserving and celebrating the contributions of players who deserve greater recognition. Saulsbery understands that baseball's enduring appeal extends beyond championship banners, Hall of Fame plaques, and the most recognizable names in the record books. Every player who reaches the major leagues has a story, and some of those stories are every bit as compelling as those of the legends celebrated throughout the sport. Whether recounting an extraordinary statistical performance, a heartbreaking personal tragedy, an ill-advised trade, or a wonderfully ridiculous clubhouse anecdote, Saulsbery writes with an unmistakable affection for both the game and the people who played it. This is a lively, nostalgic, and heartfelt tribute that should resonate especially strongly with Cardinals supporters while offering baseball enthusiasts everywhere an enjoyable opportunity to discover heroes they may never have known.

Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments

Review of “Elvis Presley: Conversations with Scotty Moore” by Jim Berkenstadt

11/7/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Score: 95/100 (9.5 out of 10)

On July 4, 1954, a young man wearing a pink shirt, pink pants with white stripes, and white shoes arrived at a modest home in Memphis, Tennessee, carrying a guitar. His name was Elvis Presley, and he was hoping to impress two musicians, guitarist Scotty Moore and bassist Bill Black, who were considering him as a potential singer for their band. Although the young man demonstrated an astonishing familiarity with seemingly every song imaginable, neither musician was particularly blown away by his audition. Yet, the following evening, the three men would stumble upon a sound that would change popular music forever!
And the world would never be the same!

In Elvis Presley: Conversations with Scotty Moore, acclaimed music historian and self-proclaimed "Rock and Roll Detective" Jim Berkenstadt offers readers a remarkable firsthand account of the birth of a musical phenomenon, told primarily through the recollections of one of its most important architects. Drawing upon conversations with Moore conducted over four years, Berkenstadt reconstructs the guitarist's extraordinary journey from his humble upbringing in rural Tennessee to his collaborations with the man who would become the King of Rock and Roll. The narrative incorporates historical photographs, original documents, concert memorabilia, recording information, and quotations from Elvis himself, creating a fascinating portrait of an era that transformed the entertainment industry.

One of the book's greatest strengths is its ability to make legendary moments in music history feel wonderfully spontaneous, personal, and human. Consider the recording of "That's All Right," which Moore explains emerged almost accidentally when Elvis began singing and clowning around during a break in an otherwise unremarkable recording session. Bill Black joined in, slapping his upright bass, and Moore followed with his guitar, prompting producer Sam Phillips to emerge from the control room and ask what they were doing. Hilariously, the musicians admitted that they didn't know! Phillips encouraged them to do it again so he could record it, leaving the three musicians trying to remember exactly what they'd just done! Equally fascinating is the story of "Blue Moon of Kentucky," which took shape when Black began singing the country waltz in a high falsetto before the musicians transformed it into something faster and more energetic. These anecdotes reveal how creativity, experimentation, individual personalities, and sheer happenstance helped produce some of the most influential recordings in American music history.

We especially appreciated how much attention is devoted to the contributions of musicians whose names haven't always received the same recognition as Elvis Presley's. Moore's descriptions of Black are particularly entertaining, portraying a talented bassist whose extraordinary sense of rhythm was matched by his outrageous sense of humor and natural ability to work an audience. D.J. Fontana's arrival adds another fascinating dimension, as Moore explains how the drummer learned to follow Elvis's movements so intuitively that the band could keep playing even when screaming audiences drowned out the music. The discussion of Moore's own guitar techniques, musical influences, Gibson instruments, and revolutionary use of the EchoSonic amplifier is similarly illuminating, offering readers a newfound appreciation for the artistry behind recordings that millions have enjoyed for generations.

There are also some wonderfully entertaining stories about life on the road! We learn about the band's early struggles to afford transportation and lodging, a disastrous automobile accident in which Black's upright bass miraculously survived, and Elvis's beloved pink Cadillac catching fire along a highway. Moore recalls the group's awkward reception at the Grand Ole Opry, where Elvis's flamboyant appearance and heavily greased hair were quite a spectacle. One particularly clever remark suggests that Elvis had so much grease in his hair that you could practically run your car on it for years! Moore also describes the overwhelming enthusiasm of audiences who had never encountered anything quite like Elvis, and increasingly chaotic performances as the young singer's popularity exploded. Such episodes bring a tremendous amount of personality, humor, and excitement to the narrative, reminding readers just how unprecedented the rise of Elvis Presley truly was.

However, that explosive popularity also created some surprisingly uncomfortable situations for the other entertainers sharing the stage. Moore recalls touring with country music star Hank Snow, whose audiences became so fixated on seeing Elvis that they sometimes showed little interest in the other performers. When Elvis appeared early, people would leave afterward; when he appeared later, they would impatiently demand his arrival throughout the preceding acts. During one particularly memorable concert, Snow finally interrupted his performance and promised the restless audience that they'd get "the little bastard" out to finish the show if they'd let him complete his song! It's an absolutely hilarious anecdote, although there's something genuinely sad about established entertainers having their performances overshadowed in such a humiliating fashion. Moore himself expresses sympathy for Snow, recognizing how difficult and discouraging these experiences must have been.

The book also contains fascinating details about Elvis's concerts in Hawaii, including his November 11, 1957, performance at Schofield Barracks, which Moore identifies as the singer's final public concert before entering the Army. This particular location carries a personal connection for us at Outstanding Creator Awards, as one of our founders used to visit Schofield Barracks frequently to go bowling! Discovering that Elvis Presley had performed at a place so familiar to one of us was an unexpected and delightful surprise. It's one of the joys of reading such an extensively researched historical account: occasionally, a seemingly ordinary geographical detail can suddenly make history feel remarkably close to home.

However, some of the book's most compelling material concerns what happened behind the scenes as Elvis became an international superstar. Moore offers candid, frequently scathing observations about Colonel Tom Parker, the financial arrangements surrounding the band, and the gradual marginalization of the musicians who helped establish Elvis's original sound. His recollections of receiving little financial recognition for historically significant recordings are frustrating, especially considering the enormous commercial success those recordings ultimately achieved. Particularly disheartening is the revelation that when Elvis received a gold record for "Heartbreak Hotel," his fellow musicians received no equivalent recognition, despite having contributed so significantly to the recording. It's an unfortunate illustration of how the entertainment industry can celebrate the individual standing in the spotlight while overlooking the talented people who helped put that individual there.

Equally disheartening is Moore's account of Elvis's increasingly formulaic film career, during which the creative freedom and musical spontaneity that characterized the early years became increasingly difficult to recapture. Moore's perspective is unmistakably personal, and while some of his interpretations of other people's motives remain speculative, that very candor makes his testimony extraordinarily engaging. His recollections also encourage readers to consider how different Elvis's career might have been if he had retained greater control over his musical direction and professional relationships.

Another particularly interesting aspect is Moore's characterization of Elvis himself. Beneath the spectacular performances, extravagant lifestyle, and larger-than-life public image emerges a young man who loved music, enjoyed experimenting with different styles, and often seemed reluctant to challenge the powerful individuals controlling his career. Yet, there are also some genuinely touching glimpses of his consideration for others, including a handwritten letter in which Elvis personally responds to a fan, provides updates about his upcoming appearances and recordings, and offers to send an autographed photograph. It's delightful to see such a personal exchange from an entertainer whose fame would eventually become so enormous that responding individually to admirers would be practically impossible. Elvis's remarks about his reluctance to disappoint fans seeking autographs, even when the crowds became overwhelming, further reveal someone who genuinely appreciated the people supporting him.

We also found it fascinating to learn how Moore viewed the very music he helped popularize. He expresses a dislike for the term "rock and roll," arguing that Elvis's recordings were better understood as popular music, drawing upon numerous musical traditions rather than belonging to one narrowly defined genre. Moore even recalls Elvis disliking the title "King of Rock and Roll," reportedly believing that there was only one King, and it wasn't him. This is an especially interesting observation considering how inseparable Elvis's identity has become from that title. It also reinforces the enormous diversity of musical influences that shaped his career, including country, gospel, rhythm and blues, and traditional pop.

The narrative eventually returns to the legendary 1968 Comeback Special, bringing the story full circle in a deeply poignant fashion. Moore's account of reuniting with Elvis and D.J. Fontana is delightful, particularly his recollection of Elvis unexpectedly asking to exchange guitars during the performance. More significant, however, is the revelation that Elvis privately approached his former bandmates afterward about the possibility of touring Europe and recording together again at Moore's Nashville studio. The prospect of these musicians rekindling their creative partnership after so many years is genuinely exciting, making the realization that these ambitions would never materialize especially heartbreaking. It's difficult to finish these passages without wondering what extraordinary music might have emerged had those plans become reality.

Berkenstadt deserves considerable praise for preserving Moore's distinctive voice throughout the narrative. The guitarist is refreshingly unpretentious, occasionally profane, frequently hilarious, and remarkably modest about his own accomplishments, even when discussing musical innovations that helped inspire generations of guitarists. Indeed, the opening tributes from such legendary musicians as Keith Richards, George Harrison, and Paul McCartney establish just how profoundly his work influenced the development of rock music. The inclusion of archival photographs, original contracts, promotional materials, and a selected discography further enhances the book's historical appeal. Although the abundance of recording dates, personnel changes, technical explanations, and session details can occasionally interrupt the narrative's momentum, these elements also make the work a valuable resource for dedicated music historians and enthusiasts.

One especially admirable quality is Moore's willingness to acknowledge the limitations of his own memory. Rather than presenting every recollection as indisputable fact, he occasionally admits uncertainty about particular dates, conversations, and circumstances, allowing readers to recognize the distinction between documented history and one individual's perspective. This honesty is important in an oral history covering events that occurred decades earlier, and it ultimately adds credibility and authenticity to his storytelling. Berkenstadt's decision to preserve these uncertainties helps maintain the conversational quality that makes the book so appealing.

We also want to recognize something that Berkenstadt consistently accomplishes throughout his work as a music historian. In March 2025, we had the pleasure of reviewing his fascinating book The Beatle Who Vanished, which earned an impressive 94/100 from Outstanding Creator Awards and subsequently secured the #23 position among our Top 25 Ranked Non-Fiction Books of 2025 in our prestigious 2025 Book of the Year Awards!

That extraordinary work explored the largely forgotten story of Jimmie Nicol, the drummer who temporarily replaced Ringo Starr for thirteen days during The Beatles' legendary 1964 world tour. Berkenstadt meticulously investigated Nicol's life before and after his brief moment of international stardom, following an astonishing trail of clues and mysteries surrounding the musician's eventual disappearance from public life. We were especially impressed by the author's extraordinary persistence in uncovering the story of someone who had experienced the absolute heights of Beatlemania, only to fade into relative obscurity.

It's wonderful to see that same passion for overlooked musical history demonstrated here! While audiences around the world celebrate legendary entertainers such as Elvis Presley and The Beatles, there are countless musicians, collaborators, producers, and other creative individuals whose contributions have received comparatively little recognition. Berkenstadt has demonstrated a remarkable commitment to uncovering their stories, documenting their accomplishments, and ensuring that their places in music history aren't forgotten. Whether he's investigating the mysterious fate of a drummer who briefly performed alongside the most famous band in the world or preserving the recollections of the guitarist who helped create the King's unmistakable sound, his appreciation for these individuals is unmistakable. There's something admirable and genuinely meaningful about an author who repeatedly shines a light on the people standing in the shadows of the spotlight. This book exemplifies that mission beautifully, giving one of rock and roll's most influential yet comparatively underappreciated musicians an opportunity to tell his extraordinary story in his own words.

This is a tremendous tribute to a musician whose fingerprints are all over the history of popular music. Elvis Presley may have become one of the most recognizable entertainers who ever lived, but the extraordinary sounds that helped propel him to superstardom were the products of collaboration, creativity, perseverance, and the contributions of individuals whose stories deserve to be remembered. Through Scotty Moore's recollections, Jim Berkenstadt invites readers into recording studios, automobiles, concert halls, and private conversations that shaped a cultural revolution. It's an informative, nostalgic, frequently hilarious, and occasionally heartbreaking journey through one of the most consequential periods in entertainment history.

An outstanding work of musical history and a fitting celebration of one of rock and roll's true pioneers!

Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments

Review of “Kay, the Girl Who Didn't Want to Go to Bed” by Brenda Minor

11/6/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
​Score: 93+/100 (9.3+ out of 10)

For a child with a boundless imagination, there simply aren't enough hours in the day! There are adventures to be had, animals to become, places to explore, and wonderful things to discover. Unfortunately, there's one unavoidable obstacle standing between an imaginative little girl named Kay and all the excitement she wishes to experience: bedtime! In Kay, the Girl Who Didn't Want to Go to Bed, author Brenda Minor presents a charming, colorful, and relatable children's story about the joys of childhood, the wonders of imagination, and the importance of finding a healthy balance between activity and rest.

Kay is an energetic girl who loves spending her days imagining extraordinary possibilities. One moment, she's a mighty elephant, and the next, she's a tiny bird perched in a tree. She might travel slowly through the water atop her friendly turtle, Dwayne, or soar across the sky as the pilot of her very own airplane! Her adventures also include examining rocks, feeling the softness of a kitten's fur, and swinging so high that she nearly touches the sun. However, when the moon rises and the day draws to a close, Kay becomes terribly upset, repeatedly declaring that she doesn't want to go to bed. Eventually, through her love of imagination and creativity, she discovers that nighttime offers something wonderful of its own: the opportunity to sleep, dream, and prepare for another exciting day.

One of the book's most appealing qualities is its playful presentation of contrasting concepts. Big and small, fast and slow, hard and soft, up and down, and day and night are cleverly incorporated into Kay's adventures, giving young readers opportunities to explore opposites while enjoying the story. The colorful illustrations, featuring character artwork by Heather Cash, help bring these concepts to life through cheerful imagery and expressive characters. The recurring scenes of Kay protesting bedtime also establish a recognizable pattern that children can anticipate and participate in during read-aloud sessions. The book's simple rhyming language makes it accessible to younger audiences, while an interactive activity at the end reinforces the educational concepts introduced throughout the narrative.

Interestingly, we were initially somewhat underwhelmed and even a little disarmed by the book's simplicity. The illustrations appeared remarkably basic, and the writing seemed equally straightforward. However, the more we read, the more we began to appreciate what Minor had accomplished. As the beautifully repetitive, almost poetic structure gradually revealed itself, our initial reservations gave way to genuine affection for the story. There's a delightful rhythm to Kay's adventures and her recurring protests against bedtime, making this an especially fun and enjoyable book to read aloud to children, particularly as part of a nightly bedtime routine. What initially seemed overly simplistic ultimately became one of the book's greatest strengths, allowing its warmth, humor, and familiarity to shine through.

There's also something particularly endearing about the personal inspiration behind this story. In her author's biography, Minor explains that she herself would sit and repeatedly protest bedtime as a little girl, a childhood memory that her siblings continued to share with her throughout the years. That autobiographical connection lends the story a genuine sense of warmth and affection. Kay's frustration feels familiar because it reflects an experience countless children and parents have encountered. Heck, even as adults, we sometimes can't stand the thought of going to bed!

There are still things we want to accomplish, experiences we don't want to miss, and responsibilities that make us feel as though we're falling behind whenever we stop to rest. This makes Kay's predicament surprisingly universal, adding another layer of relatability to an otherwise simple children's story. Rather than portraying her imagination as something that needs to be restrained, the author celebrates her curiosity and enthusiasm while gently introducing the importance of rest. Although the resolution is relatively simple and some of the rhymes could flow more smoothly, the book's sincerity, repetition, and straightforward message are well suited to its intended young audience.

Kay, the Girl Who Didn't Want to Go to Bed is a delightful celebration of childhood imagination with an encouraging lesson about balance and healthy bedtime habits. Its vibrant illustrations, imaginative adventures, educational elements, and relatable protagonist make it an inviting choice for parents, caregivers, and educators seeking an entertaining read-aloud experience. Perhaps its most meaningful message is that going to sleep doesn't mean abandoning the wonderful possibilities of childhood. After all, tomorrow brings another opportunity for adventure, and even while we're sleeping, our imaginations can continue to flourish through our dreams!

Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments

Review of “Space Shield The Wrath of the Sun” by Jeremy Clift

11/5/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Score: 92/100 (9.2 out of 10)

“Humanity has just survived the greatest solar threat since the dawn of civilization.”

That extraordinary declaration, delivered by the powerful industrialist Howie Rich, captures the immense stakes of Jeremy Clift's Space Shield: The Wrath of the Sun, an ambitious and often gripping science-fiction thriller about humanity's struggle to survive a catastrophic solar event. The third installment in Clift's Sci-Fi Galaxy series combines elaborate scientific concepts, corporate intrigue, political unrest, compelling personal conflicts, and some truly spectacular disaster sequences. When we reviewed Born in Space, we were simultaneously impressed and frustrated by the author's enormous imagination, finding much to admire in his extraordinary fictional universe while criticizing the convoluted storytelling, excessive technological exposition, and overwhelming number of characters. Here, Clift returns with another expansive adventure that demonstrates meaningful improvement in several of those areas while exploring some fascinating questions about technological advancement, corporate power, and humanity's fundamental right to survive.

The story begins in El Azuzul, Mexico, where Doctor Elena Canek and Tara participate in an archaeological excavation that uncovers an ancient Olmec mosaic containing mysterious mathematical and celestial patterns. What initially appears to be an extraordinary historical artifact becomes considerably more disturbing when its arrangements suggest that an ancient civilization may have anticipated a recurring cosmic catastrophe. Tara's discoveries eventually attract the attention of astronomer Noel Ward, who recognizes unsettling connections between the mosaic and increasingly unpredictable solar activity. We particularly appreciated how Clift uses an ancient civilization's understanding of the heavens to introduce a threat that humanity's most advanced scientific institutions may be unable to overcome. The contrast between ancient knowledge and futuristic technology establishes an intriguing mystery while raising questions about how much humanity truly understands about the universe.

The danger becomes increasingly apparent as powerful solar disturbances begin wreaking havoc across the globe, and this is where the novel delivers some of its most impressive writing and storytelling. The chapter titled "The Glancing Blow" is particularly memorable, presenting a worldwide sequence of increasingly alarming incidents that reminded us of something straight out of a Roland Emmerich disaster movie, such as The Day After Tomorrow or 2012. We have flickering lights and transportation failures in Paris, fires and electrical catastrophes around Marseille, malfunctioning solar infrastructure in India, and deadly transportation accidents in Lagos and Jakarta. Hospitals lose critical connections, emergency systems become unreliable, and ordinary people find themselves confronting the terrifying realization that the technology governing their daily lives can suddenly fail without warning. Clift effectively communicates the immense scale of the danger through a succession of localized disasters, each revealing another vulnerability in humanity's interconnected civilization.

We especially enjoyed the sensory descriptions accompanying these events. In India, a technician describes the electrically charged atmosphere as resembling a thunderstorm inside one's skull, while in Beijing, a mysterious and corrupted transmission from an Earth-Sun relay produces an unsettling sound when researchers attempt to reconstruct it. Some interpret the resulting audio as interference, while others hear something resembling a scream. The latter detail is particularly haunting, almost as though the approaching catastrophe has acquired a voice of its own. We also liked how Clift presents the disturbances differently depending on the location. In some places, the danger manifests through electrical failures, strange sounds, or increasingly disturbing scientific readings; elsewhere, it produces immediate destruction and loss of life. Rather than simply announcing that a massive solar event has struck Earth, the author allows us to experience its consequences through many different perspectives. The result is remarkably cinematic, and the sequence is among the strongest examples of how his expansive narrative style can work to his advantage.

The situation becomes increasingly desperate as the world's scientific and political institutions confront the possibility of an unprecedented solar catastrophe. Satellites, communications networks, electrical grids, transportation systems, and other essential technologies face the prospect of widespread destruction. Humanity's proposed solution is Project Kavach, an immense orbital shield constructed using lunar resources and designed to protect Earth against devastating solar radiation. It is an extraordinary engineering undertaking, and Clift clearly enjoys exploring the technical challenges associated with building something of such immense scale. His descriptions of lunar manufacturing facilities, autonomous machinery, orbital infrastructure, and complex defense systems demonstrate considerable imagination and an admirable commitment to scientific detail.

This brings us to one of our biggest criticisms of Born in Space: the author's tendency to overwhelm the narrative with technological explanations and worldbuilding. We have always believed that scientific concepts and fictional technologies should enhance a story rather than compete with its characters and conflicts for attention. Here, Clift demonstrates improvement by giving much of that scientific material a clearer narrative purpose. The construction and operation of Kavach are directly connected to humanity's survival, providing readers with a more immediate reason to care about the machinery, engineering challenges, and technical setbacks. There are still passages that become unnecessarily dense, and some explanations could be condensed without sacrificing their scientific credibility. Nevertheless, the relationship between the technological elements and the larger story feels more purposeful than it did in the original installment.

Another welcome development concerns the overarching narrative. In our earlier review, we criticized the frequent perspective shifts that repeatedly pulled our attention away from characters we were beginning to appreciate. We particularly remember Guy Zephron, whose exciting introduction and moral struggles showed tremendous promise before his storyline became overshadowed by the novel's numerous other developments. This installment retains Clift's preference for an extensive cast and multiple interconnected storylines, but the approaching solar catastrophe provides a clearer unifying objective. Whether the narrative shifts to a lunar construction site, a scientific observatory, a political confrontation, or a threatened community on Earth, the events generally relate to the same growing crisis. We still encountered moments when the constant changes in perspective disrupted the momentum, but the overall direction is easier to follow.

Perhaps the most compelling aspect of the novel is its exploration of the relationship between technological innovation and corporate power. Howie Rich, a character readers will recognize from Born in Space, assumes an increasingly troubling role as his Consortium gains control over Project Kavach. What should represent humanity's greatest collective achievement becomes an opportunity to consolidate extraordinary financial and political influence. The possibility that protection from a planetary catastrophe could depend on a city's ability or willingness to pay is genuinely disturbing. Clift effectively transforms a technological marvel into an instrument of economic coercion, forcing readers to consider whether something essential to human survival should ever become private property.

This conflict is especially interesting because it represents a natural progression of the ethical questions explored in the earlier novel. In Born in Space, the scientist Cesar embodied the dangers of scientific experimentation conducted without adequate moral restraint or institutional oversight. His reproductive experiments, genetic manipulation, and willingness to exploit human beings in pursuit of extraordinary discoveries illustrated how dangerous scientific ambition could become when detached from fundamental ethical principles. Here, Clift broadens that concern from the manipulation of individual lives to the possible exploitation of entire populations. The central question evolves from whether scientists should possess unrestricted freedom to experiment into whether corporations should possess unrestricted authority over technologies capable of determining humanity's survival. We appreciate this thematic continuity because it gives the series an intellectual identity extending beyond its futuristic settings and elaborate scientific concepts.

Arturo Rich, Howie's son, emerges as one of the story's strongest characters. His struggles with his father's expectations, intimidating influence, and increasingly questionable decisions create an engaging conflict that feels personal despite the extraordinary circumstances surrounding it. Arturo wants to prove himself capable of overseeing Kavach, but his responsibilities gradually force him to confront the moral consequences of the system he is helping construct. We found his development particularly effective because his desire for independence is complicated by a recognizable need for parental approval. The emotional tension between father and son gives the larger political and economic conflict a much-needed human dimension.

There are also some genuinely nice examples of descriptive writing throughout the novel, particularly when Clift uses imagery to convey a character's emotional state. One of our favorite examples occurs when Arturo reflects on his father's intimidating authority and his own feelings of inadequacy. Clift writes that Howie had worn power as though it were an inseparable part of himself, whereas Arturo wore it “like armor that didn’t quite fit.” We really liked this metaphor because it captures the essential difference between the two characters with remarkable economy. For Howie, power is practically second nature, while Arturo struggles beneath the responsibilities, expectations, and privileges associated with his family name. The image of ill-fitting armor also suggests that something intended to provide strength and protection can become uncomfortable, burdensome, and restrictive. This is an excellent example of how a simple metaphor can communicate more about a character than a lengthy explanation of his internal struggles.

Arturo's relationship with Airi Abe is another highlight. Airi's courage, professional competence, and willingness to challenge difficult circumstances make her a valuable presence in the story, while their developing affection gives Arturo something deeply personal to protect. We previously identified Hunter and Kiana's relationship as one of our favorite aspects of Born in Space, largely because their connection felt natural and earned amid an otherwise chaotic narrative. Teagan and Julian also demonstrated the author's ability to create appealing romantic dynamics when he allowed them sufficient time to develop. Arturo and Airi continue this tradition, bringing tenderness and emotional vulnerability into a story dominated by extraordinary scientific and political pressures. Their relationship is particularly important because it helps us care about Arturo as an individual rather than merely as the son of a powerful industrialist.

Speaking of Kiana, we were delighted to see her return. Readers may remember that we identified her as our favorite character in Born in Space, particularly appreciating her development as a cadet-turned-spy and the natural chemistry she shared with Hunter Ward. In fact, Kiana went on to win our Outstanding Creator Award for Best Supporting Character at the 2025 Clash of Champions, while she and Hunter also received an honorable mention for Best Couple. We felt that these distinctions were well deserved because Kiana demonstrated the author's considerable ability to create engaging and memorable characters, even when the surrounding narrative struggled with focus and pacing. Her return is welcome, and her interactions with Hunter provide a sense of continuity that rewards longtime readers. They also remind us of the considerable emotional potential that has always existed within this expansive fictional universe.

We also enjoyed revisiting other characters whose earlier experiences helped establish the series. Hunter Ward's struggles with dangerous neural technology introduce troubling questions about bodily autonomy, artificial intelligence, and the extent to which individuals can become instruments of another person's ambitions. Teagan's unusual connection to mysterious phenomena likewise preserves some of the larger cosmic intrigue established in Born in Space, where her extraordinary visions and the recurring symbolism surrounding the octopus suggested forces operating beyond conventional human understanding. These connections reward longtime readers and provide a sense of continuity across the increasingly expansive fictional universe.

Diana introduces another captivating dimension to this mystery. Her sensitivity to patterns and phenomena that other characters struggle to comprehend creates an intriguing contrast with the highly trained scientists attempting to understand the approaching catastrophe. We appreciate the suggestion that humanity's scientific understanding, however sophisticated, may remain incomplete when confronted with the universe's deeper complexities. The story's recurring interest in ancient civilizations, cosmic patterns, and extraordinary human perception also recalls the Indigenous cosmology explored in Born in Space, particularly its references to Apache and Hopi traditions. Clift clearly enjoys connecting cultural knowledge, scientific discovery, and speculative possibilities, and these elements help distinguish his series from more conventional space adventures.

However, we remain somewhat concerned about the author's tendency to complicate already complicated narratives. We expressed a similar criticism in our earlier review, observing that writers can become so absorbed in developing elaborate concepts and interconnected mysteries that they risk losing their readers along the way. The ancient mosaic, unusual abilities, scientific calculations, artificial intelligence, political maneuvering, and technological emergencies all compete for attention at various points. Much of this material is interesting, but a novel does not necessarily become better simply because it contains more ideas. Occasionally, we wished Clift would concentrate longer on a particular character or emotional development before introducing another complication. His imagination remains one of his greatest strengths, although greater selectivity would make that imagination even more effective.

The political conflicts surrounding Kavach are especially thought-provoking. As the Consortium attempts to monetize planetary protection, communities and governments begin questioning the legitimacy of allowing a private organization to determine who deserves protection from a catastrophe. Resistance movements emerge, and Clift explores how understandable grievances can develop into increasingly dangerous confrontations. Ofentse Mataka provides an interesting example of someone whose opposition to concentrated corporate power arises from legitimate concerns, even as his actions expose the dangers of ideological extremism. The novel understands that opposition to injustice does not automatically make every action undertaken in its name morally acceptable. This complexity adds substance to the political narrative and helps prevent the conflict from becoming a simplistic struggle between wealthy villains and righteous revolutionaries.

As the crisis intensifies, the narrative becomes increasingly suspenseful, culminating in an extraordinary confrontation with the Sun's destructive power. The technical failures, emergency repairs, difficult decisions, and desperate attempts to preserve Kavach's functionality create a palpable sense of urgency. Some of the most effective sequences involve characters confronting physical dangers that cannot be resolved through authority, wealth, or sophisticated machinery alone. The events surrounding the devastating hyperflare and the sacrifices made during the struggle to keep the shield operational are particularly memorable. The descriptions of overwhelming light, violent structural vibrations, and machinery pushed beyond its tolerances are immersive and frequently spectacular. Once again, we couldn't help imagining these sequences as scenes from a major Hollywood disaster film, with enormous visual effects and rapidly shifting perspectives showing the fate of humanity hanging in the balance.

However, what makes these sequences particularly effective is the contrast between the immense scale of the catastrophe and the vulnerability of the individuals struggling to survive it. Arturo and Airi's attempts to remain together amid the chaos create moments of genuine tenderness and fear, while the courage displayed by those responsible for keeping the shield operational adds emotional weight to the technological spectacle. Tate's sacrifice, in particular, introduces a powerful human cost into a story that could otherwise become overly preoccupied with engineering accomplishments. Moments like these remind us that the emotional impact of a disaster often comes from the individuals who must confront it rather than the magnitude of the disaster itself.

The novel's handling of family relationships also deserves recognition. Arturo's confrontation with his father, Hunter's responsibilities, Teagan's continuing involvement in the larger mystery, and the emotional consequences of personal sacrifice create meaningful connections between the extraordinary events and familiar human experiences. Family has remained an important theme throughout the Sci-Fi Galaxy series, and Clift continues exploring the ways that loyalty, resentment, love, grief, and responsibility influence decisions made under immense pressure. We were particularly pleased when the narrative allowed these relationships to take precedence over technological exposition. Such moments demonstrate the author's ability to create characters whose experiences can resonate beyond the science-fiction setting.

Nevertheless, we would have liked more consistent emotional development throughout the story. Certain major events occur so quickly that readers receive limited opportunities to process their consequences before the narrative moves elsewhere. The extensive supporting cast remains difficult to balance, and some characters inevitably receive less attention than their narrative importance seems to warrant. We also occasionally found the dialogue somewhat explanatory, with characters explicitly articulating political or ethical positions that might have been more effectively communicated through their actions. These concerns resemble those we expressed about Born in Space, although we believe they are less disruptive here because the story possesses a more clearly defined central conflict.

There is also a notable improvement in the consistency of the atmosphere. One of our frustrations with the original novel involved its occasionally awkward movement between whimsical humor, intensely violent incidents, technological speculation, and serious personal tragedy. Some of those transitions produced considerable tonal whiplash. Here, the impending solar catastrophe establishes a more sustained atmosphere of uncertainty and danger. There are quieter moments involving relationships and personal reflection, but they generally feel connected to the growing crisis rather than detached from it. The global disaster sequences are especially effective in this regard because their mounting tension gives even relatively ordinary conversations and technical discussions a sense of impending consequence.

The concluding chapters bring several of the novel's central concerns into sharper focus, particularly the question of how Kavach should be governed after the immediate catastrophe has passed. The struggle over the shield's future reinforces the idea that creating a technology capable of saving humanity is only part of the challenge. Establishing the principles by which that technology should operate may prove equally difficult. We appreciated how the resolution acknowledges the dangers of concentrated authority while leaving room for further uncertainty. The return to the ancient mosaic and Diana's developing awareness of deeper cosmic patterns also provide an intriguing connection to the opening mystery, suggesting that the universe may still hold discoveries that fundamentally challenge humanity's understanding of its place within it.


When Jeremy Clift responded to our review of Born in Space, he promised that subsequent installments would be tighter. We remembered that comment while evaluating this novel, and we believe he has made meaningful progress toward fulfilling that promise.

The storytelling remains ambitious, technically detailed, and occasionally overcomplicated, but the stronger central conflict, more purposeful integration of scientific concepts, and compelling relationship between Arturo and Howie give the narrative greater coherence. We also want to recognize the author's descriptive writing, which occasionally produces some truly memorable imagery. The contrast between Arturo's ill-fitting armor and his father's seemingly effortless authority is an excellent example, while the worldwide solar disturbances demonstrate Clift's capacity to create tension and spectacle through carefully selected details. We still encourage the author to exercise restraint when introducing new characters, technological explanations, and competing subplots. His fictional universe is already fascinating; he does not need to demonstrate the full extent of its complexity at every opportunity.

Space Shield: The Wrath of the Sun is an imaginative, intellectually stimulating, and often emotionally engaging science-fiction thriller that represents a welcome progression in Jeremy Clift's storytelling. Its exploration of corporate power, technological dependence, political responsibility, and humanity's vulnerability to cosmic forces gives the narrative considerable substance, while its spectacular disaster sequences provide some of the most exciting and memorable moments in the series thus far.

Although we continue to have reservations about the pacing, extensive exposition, and occasionally uneven characterization, the novel benefits from a stronger sense of direction, some genuinely memorable conflicts, and passages of impressive descriptive writing. The most compelling idea is that humanity could develop the extraordinary ability to protect an entire planet while still struggling to answer a much more fundamental question: Who should possess the power to decide which lives are worth protecting? That question elevates this ambitious adventure into a meaningful examination of the ethical challenges that may accompany humanity's greatest technological achievements.

Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments

Review of “The Gray” by Fred C. Falcon

11/4/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Score: 92/100 (9.2 out of 10)

Time can take a person anywhere. It can also strand them in a world they no longer recognize, separate them from everyone they love, and turn their closest friend into their greatest threat. In The Gray, Fred C. Falcon returns to the enormous science-fiction universe he established in The Box, delivering a darker, more emotionally complex sequel that expands the mythology of his original novel in some fascinating directions. What began as an extraordinary mystery surrounding an alien artifact with the ability to facilitate time travel has evolved into a dangerous struggle over the very nature of time, civilization, and human existence.

When we reviewed the original novel in August 2023, we awarded it a commendable 91+/100, recognizing the author's tremendous ambition, creativity, and imagination. We were particularly impressed by its elaborate science-fiction concepts, intricate mysteries, and sprawling cast of characters, which reminded us of television series such as Lost, Heroes, and The 4400. However, we also criticized its occasionally overwhelming complexity, believing that the abundance of characters, timelines, and competing storylines sometimes made the narrative unnecessarily difficult to follow. We're pleased to report that this sequel demonstrates some meaningful improvements, although several of those original concerns remain.

The story continues the adventures of Hopper Nielsen, a young boy entrusted with transporting the mysterious Box of Enlightenment through time and presenting it to individuals capable of advancing civilization. Accompanying him is Teddy McCorkle, whose unexpected involvement in the events of the previous novel has created complications that neither fully understands. As the two travel across different historical periods, encountering remarkable individuals and witnessing the possibilities of human achievement, Teddy develops an increasingly troubling fascination with the Box. Their friendship becomes one of the novel's most compelling elements, especially as the forces manipulating Teddy threaten to destroy the trust between them.

We particularly enjoyed the author's treatment of Teddy, who emerges as one of the sequel's most psychologically interesting characters. Having spent much of his life belittled, dismissed, and desperate for his father's approval, Teddy possesses deep emotional wounds that make him particularly vulnerable to manipulation. His longing to possess the Box gradually develops into something resembling an obsession, yet his affection for Hopper remains genuine, creating a powerful internal struggle between friendship, insecurity, and temptation. There's something profoundly tragic about watching a character who desperately wants to be important risk losing the person who has finally made him feel valued.

Another impressive development is the expanded mythology surrounding the Box, the extraterrestrial civilization of Davindore, and the mysterious substance known as the gray. Through the histories of Vandra, Commander Grinton, and Kuat, the author explores the origins of the Box's extraordinary capabilities and the dangerous consequences of attempting to manipulate forces beyond one's understanding. Particularly fascinating is Kuat's designation as the "Protector of Histories, Keeper of The Box," a title that carries considerable significance as he reveals the history of his civilization, the discovery of the Box, and his own troubling involvement in the experiments that ultimately unleashed such a dangerous force. His reflections on the consequences of his decisions raise important questions about responsibility, ambition, and the dangers of pursuing knowledge without adequately considering its consequences.

We also appreciated the explanation of the gray itself, which is described as the "anti-Box," a mysterious entity that feeds upon doubt and insecurity and possesses an apparently insatiable appetite for destruction. One particularly clever analogy compares the Box to an older sibling tasked with keeping a mischievous younger sibling under control. Under ordinary circumstances, the Box can restrain the gray's unpredictable and destructive tendencies, but when that control weakens, the consequences can be catastrophic. This explanation provides an intriguing new perspective on the dangers faced by Travelers, especially those unfortunate children who become lost within the gray's seemingly endless nothingness. It also introduces a fascinating duality between enlightenment and destruction, suggesting that the very force responsible for humanity's advancement may be connected to something capable of bringing about its downfall.

The character of Hedra also adds considerable depth to the narrative. Her experiences of devastating loss, physical suffering, and emotional trauma provide a tragic foundation for her relentless pursuit of the Box, allowing readers to understand the desperation behind her increasingly dangerous decisions. We appreciated how her relationship with Commander Grinton develops alongside his own ambitions, creating a partnership built upon conflicting desires, manipulation, and the promise of recovering what has been lost. The resulting conflict possesses a sense of historical and emotional significance that extends far beyond the immediate struggle involving Hopper and his companions.

Beyond the ambitious science-fiction concepts and elaborate mythology, there are some genuinely beautiful and poignant passages throughout the novel. One of our favorites involves Charles experiencing "a sudden burst of memory," as recollections of his former life return with extraordinary clarity. He remembers the Priest and Miriam, the church courtyard, the cherry blossom tree, and, most movingly, his parents. His mother appears in his memory with breathtaking clarity, while his father is remembered for his "rough hands and gentle nature." It's a wonderfully tender moment, made even more affecting by the overwhelming emotions that accompany these long-lost memories. In a story filled with extraordinary powers, ancient civilizations, and cosmic threats, this simple recollection of family and the people who once provided love and belonging reminds us of what time can take away.

Another particularly touching moment concerns Ilena, whose deteriorating memories have left her increasingly disconnected from the life she once knew. When the old woman tells her that someone will be happy to see her, Ilena struggles to remember the name Charles, recognizing something familiar without fully understanding why. The old woman's gentle reassurance, "And he knows yours, Ilena," is beautifully understated, especially considering everything these characters have experienced together. There's something heartbreaking about the possibility of forgetting people who once meant so much to us, even when those people continue to remember us. Moments such as these demonstrate the author's ability to find genuine emotional resonance within his elaborate science-fiction narrative, and we would have welcomed even more of them.

Cassie Burgess, meanwhile, continues to provide an important human perspective on the increasingly extraordinary events surrounding the Box. Her determination to protect Hopper places her in situations that challenge her professional identity, personal convictions, and understanding of right and wrong. We were especially interested in the moral dilemma involving Angela Grant, as Cassie is forced to consider whether protecting an innocent child could justify taking another person's life. Her relationship with her brother Clive provides some welcome emotional grounding, reminding readers that the consequences of these remarkable events extend to ordinary people and the families who care about them.

The novel also benefits from its imaginative use of historical settings and personalities. Encounters involving figures such as Guglielmo Marconi, Hans Christian Andersen, and Mary Anning create opportunities to explore the relationship between human innovation and the possibilities revealed by the Box. There's something wonderfully intriguing about imagining how a mysterious artifact might influence individuals whose accomplishments would eventually help shape the modern world. These sequences reinforce the author's fascination with human potential and the idea that even seemingly small decisions can produce consequences extending across generations.

Nevertheless, we would be remiss if we didn't acknowledge that the narrative remains extremely ambitious, occasionally to its own detriment. Despite being considerably shorter than its predecessor, this is still a substantial novel containing 84 chapters, numerous characters, competing factions, extensive backstories, and frequent changes in time and perspective. While many of these elements ultimately contribute to the larger story, others can feel tangential, interrupting the momentum just as a particularly interesting storyline begins gathering speed. We occasionally found ourselves wanting the author to remain with Hopper and Teddy, Cassie, or the increasingly dangerous conflict surrounding the gray rather than introduce another extended detour into a secondary character's history or circumstances.

There are also moments when the narration becomes somewhat repetitive, particularly regarding characters' fears, frustrations, and personal motivations. Teddy's internal struggle, for example, is genuinely fascinating, but the repeated emphasis on his obsession and psychological distress occasionally diminishes the impact of what are otherwise powerful developments. A little more narrative economy would help the most important scenes stand out while allowing the story's considerable momentum to carry readers forward. The elaborate worldbuilding is certainly one of the author's greatest strengths, but greater selectivity in presenting that information would make the overall experience more accessible.

The conclusion is another consideration. Without revealing too much, the author brings several important storylines to dramatic turning points while establishing the foundations for an even greater confrontation. There are satisfying revelations, dangerous betrayals, and some genuinely exciting developments, but the ending leaves numerous questions unanswered and several major conflicts unresolved. Readers who enjoy serialized science-fiction adventures will likely appreciate the anticipation, although those hoping for a more definitive resolution may find themselves wishing for a greater sense of closure.

The Gray demonstrates Fred C. Falcon's considerable imagination and growing ability to develop emotionally compelling characters within an extraordinarily ambitious fictional universe. The expanded mythology is fascinating, the stakes are significantly higher, and the relationships between several central characters provide a stronger emotional foundation than we experienced in the original novel. We were particularly impressed by the novel's more poignant moments, which explore the importance of friendship, family, memory, and belonging amid the extraordinary circumstances surrounding its characters. We still believe the author would benefit from exercising greater restraint with secondary characters, lengthy digressions, and overlapping storylines, but there's no denying the creativity, thought, and effort invested in this undertaking. For readers who enjoy intricate science-fiction mysteries, morally complicated characters, historical intrigue, and sprawling adventures that challenge them to connect the pieces, this is an ambitious and rewarding continuation of a remarkable literary project.

Check it out on Amazon!

0 Comments

Review of “The Legacy of the Twins Platoon” by Christy Sauro Jr.

11/3/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
​Score: 96/100 (9.6 out of 10)

There are impressive works of military history, and then there are works so ambitious, so meticulously researched, and so deeply personal that you can scarcely believe the amount of dedication required to bring them to life. Christy Sauro Jr.'s The Legacy of the Twins Platoon belongs firmly in the latter category. This extraordinary book is overflowing with fascinating historical discoveries, gripping firsthand accounts, unforgettable personalities, remarkable acts of courage, and astonishing stories of friendship, perseverance, and resilience. It is a tremendous accomplishment, made all the more impressive by the fact that the author was himself a member of the legendary Marine platoon whose history he has worked so tirelessly to preserve.

Consider the sheer magnitude of this undertaking. In 1984, Sauro began contemplating the possibility of documenting what had become of the Marines with whom he had served during the Vietnam War. What initially seemed like an almost impossibly ambitious project gradually developed into a personal mission, and by 1990, he had begun researching the experiences of his fellow servicemen in earnest. Over the following fifteen years, he devoted more than 17,000 hours to the project, eventually publishing his original book in 2006. Yet, even after accomplishing something so remarkable, Sauro continued uncovering new information, discovering additional stories, and expanding our understanding of these men's extraordinary lives.

The result is a magnificent historical undertaking that goes far beyond the traditional boundaries of military nonfiction. Through extensive interviews, personal correspondence, photographs, military and medical records, historical newspapers, and decades of investigative work, Sauro reconstructs the experiences of numerous Marines and the families whose lives became intertwined with theirs. What we find particularly impressive is how frequently one discovery leads to another, sometimes through astonishing coincidences, unexpected reunions, or conversations that reveal important details previously unknown even to those closest to the individuals involved. There is a wonderful sense of discovery throughout the narrative, as though the author is assembling an enormous historical puzzle, gradually revealing a much richer and more intricate picture of these men and their lasting contributions to American history.

Much of the book concerns the extraordinary difficulties these Marines encountered during their training and subsequent deployment to Vietnam. Sauro reconstructs numerous operations and engagements, including the battles around Khe Sanh, Hue City, Dai Do, and the Demilitarized Zone, providing considerable military detail without losing sight of the individuals involved. His descriptions of the demanding terrain, dangerous patrols, devastating injuries, and often desperate attempts to rescue wounded comrades convey the physical and psychological intensity of combat. Readers also encounter frightening examples of how quickly seemingly ordinary circumstances could deteriorate into deadly confrontations, sometimes leaving the difference between survival and death dependent upon chance.

What particularly impressed us, however, was the author's attention to the consequences of these experiences over the following decades, especially how physical injuries could continue worsening long after a veteran's discharge. Paul "Chuck" Ennis's story offers an extraordinary illustration of this reality, as complications stemming from his wartime injuries gradually rob him of his mobility and independence. Sauro describes years of medical procedures, infections, hospitalizations, and the demanding responsibilities assumed by Ennis's wife, Barb, and their children. In one memorable incident, medical personnel unfamiliar with a Hoyer lift receive instructions from one of Ennis's sons, demonstrating how thoroughly the family had adapted to the difficult realities of his care.

There is something simultaneously inspiring and heartbreaking about Ennis's determination to maintain his sense of humor and positive outlook despite the severity of his condition. Even as his circumstances deteriorate, he continues finding reasons to enjoy life, appreciate his family, and resist surrendering to despair. We also admire the author's recognition of Barb's remarkable dedication, including her medical knowledge and willingness to advocate for her husband during serious health emergencies. Her contributions remind us that the extraordinary endurance associated with military service can also be found among the spouses, children, and caregivers who dedicate years of their lives to supporting wounded veterans.

The experiences of Russ Adamson provide an equally compelling examination of the psychological consequences of military service, although his struggles manifest in very different ways. Despite building a family and establishing a seemingly ordinary civilian life, Adamson suffers from persistent physical pain, depression, and post-traumatic stress, eventually turning to alcohol to alleviate his suffering. His wife, Judy, becomes increasingly concerned about his behavior, and their marriage reaches a crisis before he begins confronting his difficulties and pursuing recovery. Their eventual efforts to help other veterans are especially meaningful, illustrating how painful personal experiences can sometimes develop into a lasting commitment to improving the lives of others.

Another exceptional portion of the book concerns Bruce Sommer and a deeply personal drawing he created following his return from Vietnam. Titled Anguish, the artwork depicts a man's head thrown backward in distress, with the larger image composed of numerous smaller illustrations expressing the emotional burdens associated with the war and its aftermath. For years, Sommer keeps the drawing largely hidden, reluctant to expose such an intimate expression of his suffering to others. When he eventually shares it with Diane, the sister of fellow Marine Wallace "Skip" Schmidt, the artwork helps her better understand her brother's psychological struggles and the tragic circumstances surrounding his death.

We found this account especially moving because of the unusual chain of events that brings Sommer, Diane, and Sauro together, ultimately allowing the drawing to reach a much wider audience. The artwork's eventual acquisition by a veterans' museum becomes an important acknowledgment of both Sommer's artistic achievement and the experiences represented within it. There is something wonderfully meaningful about an intensely private expression of anguish becoming a means through which others can better understand the suffering of an entire generation. The story also illustrates how meaningful recognition and human connection can emerge many years after the experiences that inspired them.

Another element that deserves praise is Sauro's inclusion of the veterans' complicated feelings about their service, including memories that continue troubling them despite the passage of decades. Brad Juntunen, for example, remembers a North Vietnamese soldier he killed and continues thinking about the family photograph associated with the man, recognizing the devastating consequences that death likely had for those who loved him. Later, after spending approximately forty years searching for the grave of fellow Marine Kenny Baldwin, Juntunen finally finds it and reflects upon the wife, children, and grandchildren he has been fortunate enough to know. His recognition that Baldwin would never experience those same blessings is extraordinarily poignant, revealing the weight of survivor's guilt and the lifelong responsibilities some veterans feel toward their fallen comrades.

There is also a particularly touching account involving Rick White, whose older half-brother, Charles, was killed during the war. Rick was just an infant when Charles served in the Marines, and he grew up knowing his brother largely through photographs, family stories, and the possessions he left behind. At one point, Rick places his hand inside Charles's old baseball mitt, feeling a little closer to the brother he never really had the opportunity to know. It is a seemingly insignificant gesture, yet it captures something profound about remembrance and the extraordinary number of lives affected by the loss of a single soldier.

The book also contains several moments of long-overdue recognition that are genuinely uplifting. Particularly memorable is the Minnesota Twins organization's decision to honor members of the original platoon during events at Target Field, allowing veterans and their families to receive public expressions of gratitude decades after their service. Clayton Carr, who lost a leg during the Battle of Hue City, participates in one such ceremony, and the appreciation he receives from strangers carries tremendous personal significance. Following his death, a floral arrangement sent by the baseball organization becomes a cherished keepsake for his young grandson, providing another touching illustration of how these acts of remembrance can resonate across generations.

The author's account of Diane Finnemann's advocacy is equally commendable, as her dedication to honoring Vietnam veterans develops into an extraordinary series of commemorative and legislative efforts. Her involvement in securing greater recognition for these servicemen, including the establishment of Vietnam Veterans Day in Minnesota, demonstrates how an individual's determination can influence an entire community. We especially appreciate that Sauro documents the practical work required to achieve such recognition, rather than simply presenting the eventual ceremonies and celebrations. These developments give the book a valuable sense of historical continuity, revealing how individual experiences of grief and injustice can ultimately inspire meaningful social change.

We also believe the book raises important questions about the responsibilities of governments, military institutions, and society toward individuals who have endured the consequences of armed conflict. How should a nation respond when veterans return with injuries that remain invisible or poorly understood? What obligations exist toward the families whose lives are permanently altered by military service? And how can the experiences of those who are no longer alive be preserved accurately and respectfully for generations that never witnessed the events themselves? Sauro addresses these questions through the personal accounts he has spent so many years collecting, giving the work relevance that extends far beyond its immediate historical setting.

The Legacy of the Twins Platoon is an exceptional achievement in historical nonfiction, distinguished by its extraordinary research, extensive collection of personal testimonies, and deeply compassionate treatment of veterans and their families. Its accounts of sacrifice, suffering, resilience, friendship, and remembrance are often tremendously affecting, while the author's decades of investigative work give the material an authenticity and emotional significance that few conventional military histories can match. Perhaps most importantly, the book demonstrates how much history remains to be discovered through the memories of ordinary people, particularly those whose experiences have never received the attention they deserve.

As the surviving members of the platoon continue growing older, the importance of Sauro's work becomes increasingly apparent. The photographs, letters, memories, and personal accounts gathered throughout these pages will remain long after the individuals themselves have passed away, preserving their experiences for descendants and future generations. We are especially moved by the thought that somewhere, a child or grandchild may someday discover something about a loved one that would otherwise have remained unknown, finding a deeper connection to someone whose life was shaped by events that occurred decades earlier. It is difficult to imagine a more meaningful legacy for an author to leave behind.

Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments

Review of “Steel Soldier: Guadalcanal Odyssey” by James J. Messina, Charles Messina

11/2/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Score: 96/100 (9.6 out of 10)

War is often remembered through famous battles, military strategies, casualty figures, and the names of generals and political leaders. Yet behind these great historical events are countless ordinary people whose lives were forever changed by extraordinary circumstances. James J. Messina was one such individual: a restless nineteen-year-old steelworker from West Aliquippa, Pennsylvania, who enlisted in the United States Marine Corps in September 1941 in search of adventure, excitement, and an escape from the monotony of civilian life. Little did he know that he would soon find himself fighting for survival in the steaming jungles of Guadalcanal, participating in one of the most brutal and consequential campaigns of World War II.

Steel Soldier is an exceptionally gritty, violent, unfiltered, and deeply human account of warfare, told through the firsthand recollections of a man who originally intended to preserve his memories for his children. Decades after the conflict, Messina painstakingly wrote and illustrated an extraordinary five-volume autobiography, which his son, Charles Messina, would eventually help bring to publication. The resulting memoir is a fascinating combination of personal storytelling, military history, archival research, historical photographs, and original artwork. Its emotional depth, authenticity, and remarkable attention to detail make it one of the most memorable World War II memoirs we have encountered, and a particularly valuable contribution to the preservation of American history.

We'll begin with our principal criticism: the first third of the book requires considerable patience. Charles Messina devotes a substantial amount of attention to his father's background, family history, and the lengthy process of assembling and publishing the manuscript, while the opening chapters focus extensively on military training, recruitment, and preparations for war. These sections contain plenty of fascinating historical details and entertaining anecdotes, but they simply aren't as compelling, dramatic, or emotionally engaging as the Guadalcanal chapters. We occasionally found our attention wandering and ourselves becoming impatient for the central conflict to begin, although we recognize that this introductory material provides important context for understanding the young man who would eventually become a battle-hardened Marine.

In fact, this gradual progression from relative innocence to the horrors of warfare is one of the memoir's more compelling underlying themes. Messina begins as an ordinary American boy who is dissatisfied with working in a steel mill and eager to experience the wider world, initially hoping to join the Navy before unexpectedly finding himself in the Marine Corps. His early experiences include making friends, enduring exhausting marches, learning military customs, and encountering drill instructors who seem to take almost sadistic pleasure in tormenting their recruits. One particularly memorable instructor repeatedly calls the men "shitheads," an insult that becomes almost hilarious through its sheer repetition, excessive aggression, and the instructor's seemingly boundless enthusiasm for humiliating everyone around him.

The descriptions of military training are also interesting because they reveal just how much military life has changed over the past eight decades. The men sleep in canvas tents, follow strict regulations governing everything from smoking to conversation, and endure a level of verbal abuse that would likely be viewed quite differently in many contemporary settings. Smoking itself seems practically universal throughout the narrative, with cigarettes appearing during transportation, recreation, military duties, and even the chaos of battle. These seemingly insignificant details help transport readers into the 1940s, offering a glimpse into the attitudes, customs, and everyday experiences of a generation that inhabited a dramatically different world.

We also appreciated the extensive attention given to military equipment, particularly the weapons and tactics employed during the early stages of World War II. Messina describes training with the M1903 Springfield bolt-action rifle, learning how to maintain his weapon, practicing bayonet drills, and eventually becoming intimately familiar with equipment that would appear antiquated compared to modern military technology. One especially entertaining moment involves his first experience firing a .45-caliber automatic pistol, when he astonishes his instructor by hitting ten consecutive bullseyes despite having never fired a handgun before. The incident demonstrates both his natural marksmanship and the effectiveness of his instructor's guidance, while adding another charming detail to an already fascinating personal history.

Another memorable example of military ingenuity occurs during the Guadalcanal campaign, when Messina learns a clever technique from another Marine who places a small piece of white paper near his rifle sight to improve his aim during nighttime combat. It is a simple but remarkably resourceful solution to an enormous problem, particularly considering the limitations of military technology at the time. Without the widespread availability of modern night-vision equipment, soldiers frequently had to improvise and rely upon whatever practical advantages they could discover. We love these little historical details because they reveal the intelligence, adaptability, and resourcefulness of ordinary fighting men whose survival often depended upon thinking quickly under extraordinary pressure.

The early chapters also contain some surprisingly touching and entertaining diversions, including Messina's recollections of a beautiful young woman named Stevie, whose presence temporarily transports the narrative into something resembling a romantic adventure. Elsewhere, the author discusses the mystery surrounding Amelia Earhart, recalls humorous encounters with fellow servicemen, and recounts the tragic loss of men swept overboard who could not be rescued. Such episodes reinforce the fact that these soldiers were young people with hopes, fears, romantic interests, friendships, and personal ambitions, many of which would be interrupted or permanently destroyed by the war. They also make the transition into Guadalcanal considerably more powerful, as the comparatively innocent world of training, travel, and youthful excitement gives way to unimaginable violence.

Once the Marines arrive at Guadalcanal, the narrative becomes substantially more gripping. The island is transformed into a nightmarish environment of oppressive heat, torrential rain, relentless insects, disease, starvation, and nearly constant danger from Japanese forces. Messina recounts navigating dense jungle vegetation, enduring artillery bombardments, confronting hidden enemy positions, and spending terrifying nights anticipating attacks from an adversary that has become extraordinarily adept at concealment and infiltration. His descriptions of fear are particularly effective because he makes little effort to conceal his own vulnerability, acknowledging the overwhelming anxiety, exhaustion, and uncertainty that accompanied even the most routine military assignments.

Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of these chapters is how the Marines seem to be fighting two separate wars: one against the Japanese military and another against the island itself. The jungle is filled with giant land crabs, snakes, spiders, scorpions, rats, wild dogs, iguanas, and countless other creatures capable of making an already miserable existence considerably worse. Mosquitoes are especially troublesome, spreading malaria and contributing to the devastating deterioration of the Marines' physical health. Messina's descriptions make Guadalcanal feel almost like a living adversary, with its suffocating vegetation, unpredictable weather, dangerous wildlife, and relentless tropical diseases presenting challenges that sometimes seem every bit as formidable as enemy gunfire.

One particularly fascinating detail involves the enormous saltwater crocodiles inhabiting the island's waterways. Messina explains that these formidable reptiles could reach extraordinary sizes, yet he never heard of anyone being attacked by them during the campaign. According to his recollection, the constant explosions and gunfire had apparently frightened many of the animals away from the areas where soldiers were fighting. There is something strangely thought-provoking about imagining creatures capable of terrifying almost any human being becoming frightened themselves by the destructive capabilities of modern warfare, particularly when considering how profoundly human conflicts can affect the natural environment and the animals inhabiting it.

The physical suffering described throughout the memoir is equally disturbing, particularly the devastating effects of malaria, poor nutrition, unsanitary conditions, and prolonged exhaustion. The Marines are frequently hungry, filthy, sleep-deprived, and increasingly debilitated, yet they must somehow continue fighting, constructing defenses, conducting patrols, and carrying out orders under extremely dangerous circumstances. Messina also recounts being knocked unconscious during an artillery bombardment, experiencing shell shock, and suffering a serious back injury that would eventually contribute to his premature retirement from civilian employment decades later. These experiences provide a sobering reminder that even soldiers fortunate enough to survive a war may continue suffering its consequences for the remainder of their lives.

Despite these horrific circumstances, the book contains a surprising amount of humor, personality, and genuine warmth. We particularly enjoyed Messina's interactions with his foul-mouthed friend Hennigan, whose endless complaints, colorful insults, and temperamental personality make him one of the memoir's most entertaining figures. Their hilariously ill-advised expedition to obtain fresh bananas is especially memorable, featuring an exhausting journey, arguments, encounters with other servicemen, the stomach-turning stench of buried Japanese soldiers, and a thoroughly anticlimactic ending when Messina discovers that his hard-earned bananas refuse to ripen. It is a wonderfully absurd episode that provides much-needed comic relief while reminding readers how desperately these men longed for something as simple as fresh fruit.

Other seemingly insignificant details prove surprisingly revealing, particularly when the men encounter conveniences that many contemporary readers would scarcely give a second thought. One memorable example involves the excitement surrounding a machine dispensing crackers and snacks, a seemingly ordinary luxury that becomes extraordinary to servicemen accustomed to inadequate rations, monotonous meals, and uncomfortable living conditions. The book contains numerous moments when fresh bread, ice cream, or other small comforts become causes for celebration. Reading these passages in an era when many Americans can walk into a convenience store and choose from an overwhelming variety of foods, drinks, and snacks offers a rather humbling perspective on how much everyday life has changed and how easily we take such comforts for granted.

The relationships between Messina and his fellow Marines are another major strength, particularly because the men are portrayed as recognizable individuals with distinctive personalities, strengths, weaknesses, and complicated feelings toward one another. Sergeant Breeding is an especially interesting character, frequently earning Messina's resentment through his abrasive manner, harsh orders, and seemingly endless criticism, yet gradually earning his respect through his competence and commitment to keeping his men alive. The relationship demonstrates how military brotherhood can develop between people who might never have become friends under ordinary circumstances. Their shared experiences forge powerful bonds of loyalty and understanding, even when personal disagreements, resentment, and frustration threaten to drive them apart.

One of the most haunting and emotionally affecting passages involves the discovery of a badly decomposed Catholic nun who, according to the account, had been murdered by Japanese soldiers alongside other missionaries on the island. The description of her body is horrific, but what follows is a remarkably tender display of compassion in the midst of unimaginable brutality. Sergeant Breeding orders the Marines to dig a grave and give her a dignified burial, after which a noncommissioned officer offers a prayer and the Catholic servicemen make the sign of the cross. This quiet moment of reverence stands out among the gunfire, suffering, and destruction, revealing how faith, compassion, and human decency can endure even under circumstances that seem designed to extinguish them.

It is particularly moving that Breeding, a man who often appears so rough, uncompromising, and emotionally hardened, is the one who orders the burial. His response reveals a compassionate side that readers might not expect from someone whose personality frequently frustrates the narrator. The incident also speaks to Messina's own deeply held religious convictions, which remain a central source of strength throughout his military service. His faith provides comfort amid uncertainty, and the memoir repeatedly emphasizes the importance of prayer, family, friendship, and the hope of surviving long enough to return home.

Another fascinating dimension of the narrative is its portrayal of the Japanese military and the indigenous peoples of the Solomon Islands. Messina frequently describes Japanese soldiers as cunning, relentless, resourceful, and extraordinarily dangerous opponents, while also recounting incidents of shocking brutality and cruelty. Yet there are moments when the humanity of the enemy emerges, particularly through encounters with captured soldiers, personal belongings, and other reminders that these men were human beings with their own fears, families, and experiences. The islanders are also important participants in the narrative, serving as guides, allies, laborers, and civilians whose lives have been profoundly disrupted by a conflict imposed upon their homeland.

It is worth mentioning that the author frequently employs derogatory terminology when referring to Japanese soldiers, reflecting attitudes and language that were commonplace among American servicemen during World War II. Such expressions may be offensive to contemporary readers, and certain generalizations about the Japanese and indigenous peoples are clearly products of their historical context. Nevertheless, preserving the narrator's original language also helps communicate the anger, fear, prejudice, and hostility that characterized the conflict. We believe this aspect of the memoir is best approached with an understanding of the historical circumstances rather than an expectation that a veteran recalling the 1940s should necessarily speak according to contemporary social conventions.

Another interesting detail concerns the practical strategies employed by the American military to counter Japanese infiltration. Messina discusses the use of passwords containing the letter L, based on the belief that Japanese infiltrators would have difficulty pronouncing certain English words correctly. This is another example of the small, fascinating pieces of historical knowledge scattered throughout the narrative, offering insight into the improvised tactics and assumptions that influenced everyday military operations. Combined with descriptions of camouflage, nighttime combat, reconnaissance, and the challenges of identifying enemy positions, such anecdotes give readers an unusually intimate understanding of how the fighting actually unfolded.

The presentation is particularly exceptional because of its extraordinary collection of original illustrations, many of which Messina created decades after the war despite having no formal artistic training. His drawings possess an unmistakably personal style, sometimes almost childlike in their proportions and simplicity, yet often remarkably expressive in their depiction of people, landscapes, and dramatic events. There is something incredibly moving about seeing the memories of a former Marine translated into artwork by the very person who experienced them, particularly when those images depict events that continued haunting him throughout his life. The illustrations give the memoir a visual personality that distinguishes it from conventional military histories, while the archival photographs, historical maps, and military documents provide an additional layer of authenticity and educational value.

Charles Messina deserves tremendous recognition for his extraordinary dedication to preserving, researching, and publishing his father's work. His efforts involved years of correspondence with military historians and government institutions, extensive archival research, the examination of military service records, and the painstaking process of identifying the men who served alongside his father. Particularly heartbreaking is the story of how one volume of the original illustrated manuscript suffered catastrophic water damage, destroying precious artwork that could never truly be replaced. Fortunately, photocopies had been made beforehand, allowing much of the material to survive, although some reproduced images inevitably lost a degree of their original quality.

The relationship between father and son is perhaps the most beautiful underlying story of all. James originally intended his autobiography as a personal gift for his children, something they could remember him by after he and their mother were gone. Charles subsequently devoted an extraordinary amount of his own life to preserving this legacy, eventually coming to believe that his father may have secretly dreamed of becoming a published author. There is something especially poignant about a man's private creative aspirations finally being realized through the devotion of his son, transforming a family keepsake into an important piece of historical literature that can now be appreciated by generations of readers.

We also appreciate the enormous amount of historical research incorporated throughout the book, although this occasionally creates some problems with pacing and narrative cohesion. Detailed descriptions of troop movements, military operations, equipment specifications, casualty statistics, and strategic developments sometimes interrupt the more intimate recollections that make Messina's storytelling so compelling. There are moments when the narrative feels like a combination of two different books: a conversational veteran's memoir and a comprehensive military history of the Guadalcanal campaign. Both approaches have considerable merit, but the transitions between them aren't always seamless, and certain passages could have benefited from tighter editing or a more deliberate balance between historical context and personal experience.

Nevertheless, the depth of research is one of the work's most impressive achievements, and it is particularly valuable considering the enormous amount of time that passed between the events themselves and the writing and publication of the memoir. The historical documentation helps establish context for the narrator's recollections, while the firsthand experiences give the broader military history an emotional immediacy that statistics and official reports can rarely achieve on their own. We also appreciate the extensive bibliography, citations, photographs, and records that demonstrate the seriousness with which Charles approached the project. His determination to honor the experiences of his father and his fellow Marines is evident on virtually every page.

Perhaps the most powerful aspect of the entire narrative is the transformation of the young man at its center. The restless steelworker who enlisted in search of excitement could never have anticipated the fear, suffering, violence, and extraordinary sacrifices that awaited him, nor the lasting physical and psychological consequences of his service. By the time Messina and his fellow Marines finally depart Guadalcanal, their exhaustion and relief are palpable, and the contrast with the eager young recruit introduced at the beginning is deeply affecting. What once seemed like an exciting opportunity to escape ordinary life has become an experience that will shape his identity, convictions, relationships, and memories for decades to come.

It is little wonder that this remarkable work would eventually become one of our most distinguished award winners, receiving our 2025 Non-Fiction Book of the Year honor and earning the Ultimate Championship in our 2025 Clash of Champions competition. Its recognition for Best Research is equally appropriate, considering the extraordinary commitment to historical preservation evident throughout its pages. We have reviewed many excellent works of historical nonfiction, but few combine such extensive documentation with the distinctive personality, original artwork, and emotional sincerity of a firsthand account created primarily as an act of love for one's family.

This is a thrilling, heartbreaking, fascinating, occasionally hilarious, and profoundly moving account of one of the defining military campaigns of World War II. Its greatest achievement is the preservation of an ordinary American's extraordinary experiences, reminding us that history is ultimately composed of individual lives, each filled with hopes, fears, friendships, accomplishments, and sacrifices that deserve to be remembered. James J. Messina's story offers readers an unforgettable perspective on courage, survival, brotherhood, faith, and the lasting human consequences of warfare, while Charles Messina's dedication transforms that personal testimony into a beautiful tribute to his father and the generation he represented. We are grateful that this remarkable manuscript survived, that its author's experiences have been preserved, and that what began as a father's private gift to his children has become a lasting legacy for the world.

Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments

Review of “Vampires in BC” by Keith Costelloe

11/1/2026

0 Comments

 
Picture
Score: 89/100 (8.9 out of 10)

Vampires have been frightening, seducing, and terrorizing humanity in literature for centuries, so finding something genuinely interesting to do with these familiar creatures is no small accomplishment. Fortunately, Keith Costelloe has quite a few ideas up his sleeve in Vampires in BC, an ambitious supernatural adventure that blends traditional vampire mythology with modern technology, corporate greed, questions of personal identity, and even the legendary Sasquatch.

What begins as a disturbing account of one young person's transformation into a vampire gradually develops into something much bigger, exploring the possibility of an organized supernatural society preparing to challenge humanity's dominance of the planet. We appreciate the author's imagination and willingness to explore so many different concepts, although we also believe the story occasionally struggles under the weight of its own ambitions.

The protagonist, Jude, is recovering from a car accident at Peace Arch Hospital when a mysterious woman known as Dr. De'Ath initiates a transformation that promises eternal life, supernatural abilities, and virtually unlimited physical freedom. However, the reality of vampirism proves considerably more complicated than the seductive promises that initially attracted Jude.

The novel introduces a distinction between powerful purebred vampires, transformed full vampires, and partially transformed humans, establishing a supernatural hierarchy in which the promise of extraordinary freedom often conceals a frightening degree of servitude. We particularly appreciate how the author explores the biological aspects of vampirism through Draculin, an anticoagulant associated with vampire saliva that plays an important role in the transformation process. These details help distinguish the story's mythology from more conventional interpretations of vampires, even when some of the accompanying scientific explanations stretch credibility.

One of the book's most intriguing developments involves the vampires' efforts to establish a sophisticated organization capable of exploiting modern human society. Rather than relying exclusively on primitive hunting instincts, these creatures recognize the advantages of wealth, technology, corporate influence, and human ambition. Their recruitment strategies promise extraordinary salaries, luxurious possessions, professional opportunities, and other rewards that appeal directly to people's desires.

We particularly enjoyed the concept of recruiting talented game developers to construct a simulation designed to anticipate how humanity might resist a vampire takeover. It is an inventive idea that transforms something ordinarily associated with entertainment into a potential instrument of domination, while also demonstrating how the vampires' own arrogance and dependence on human ingenuity could become weaknesses.

We also appreciate the author's efforts to incorporate relevant, timely, and sometimes controversial subjects into a work of supernatural fiction. The story touches upon environmental destruction, corporate exploitation, technological advancement, gender identity, sexuality, prejudice, and the complicated question of whether humanity has an exclusive claim to the planet it inhabits. Some of these subjects are particularly divisive in contemporary society, but that does not mean fiction should shy away from them. Quite the contrary!

We admire authors who are willing to engage with challenging ideas, especially when they can explore them through imaginative situations rather than simply delivering lectures or telling readers what to believe. Costelloe's supernatural premise provides opportunities to examine familiar human problems from unfamiliar perspectives, and some of the book's most interesting moments emerge from these intersections between fantasy and reality. Although not every concept receives the depth or subtlety it deserves, we commend the effort to make the story about considerably more than vampires drinking blood.

The relationship between Jude and Dr. De'Ath is another interesting component of the narrative. The latter is a manipulative, domineering figure who understands how to exploit the insecurities, ambitions, and emotional vulnerabilities of prospective recruits. Jude, meanwhile, is far more complicated than a straightforward hero or villain, possessing both a frightening appetite for blood and a lingering capacity for compassion.

The character's ability to shapeshift also provides opportunities to explore gender expression, sexuality, self-image, and the desire to escape restrictive expectations. We appreciate that these subjects are not merely introduced as abstract discussions, but become intertwined with Jude's supernatural abilities and personal relationships. There is something particularly compelling about a character who can become almost anyone physically while continuing to struggle with questions of identity, belonging, and self-acceptance.

We also found considerable emotional potential in Jude's relationship with Ong, a longtime friend whose importance extends far beyond their shared history. Jude's romantic feelings, insecurities, jealousy, and desire for companionship contribute to decisions with devastating consequences. The transformation of Ong into a full vampire is particularly significant, demonstrating how an ostensibly loving desire to remain together forever can become an act of terrible selfishness.

Jude's subsequent guilt adds meaningful complexity to the character, especially as the story increasingly explores the conflict between supernatural appetites and human conscience. We would have liked to see this emotional dimension receive even greater attention because, beneath all the elaborate world-building and supernatural spectacle, it is arguably one of the book's strongest elements.

Another character who deserves recognition is Gav, a talented teenage game developer whose intelligence, irreverence, and growing attachment to Jude contribute substantially to the story. We appreciate the contrast between his technological expertise and his youthful impulsiveness, especially when he begins recognizing the dangers of serving creatures who regard partially transformed humans as expendable.

His interactions with Jude can be entertaining, and their developing partnership provides an important counterbalance to Dr. De'Ath's authoritarian leadership. Nevertheless, his frequent wisecracks, slang, and occasionally obnoxious behavior also illustrate one of our larger concerns with the novel: its difficulty maintaining a consistent tone.

Indeed, the book's tonal inconsistency is one of its most significant weaknesses. At times, the author appears to be crafting a genuinely disturbing horror story filled with grotesque violence, psychological manipulation, enslavement, and moral corruption. At others, the narrative suddenly resembles an irreverent teenage comedy, complete with juvenile insults, sexual innuendos, sarcastic exchanges, and jokes about bodily functions.

Consider the contrast between scenes depicting horrifying vampire attacks and the comparatively lighthearted discussions about grotesque blood smoothies containing ingredients like beetroot, ginger, and bull urine. We understand that humor can provide welcome relief from an otherwise grim narrative, and we certainly do not object to horror stories having lighter moments. However, the transitions are not always handled gracefully, and the frequent shifts between gruesome horror, romantic drama, science-fiction speculation, and adolescent comedy sometimes make it difficult to take the proceedings as seriously as the author seemingly intends.

This problem occasionally extends to the characterization and dialogue. Dr. De'Ath can be an appropriately terrifying antagonist, particularly when exploiting vulnerable people or treating human lives as disposable resources. Yet her exaggerated mannerisms, theatrical declarations, and almost cartoonishly villainous behavior sometimes undermine that menace.

Similarly, Jude and Gav's conversations can shift from discussing matters of life and death to trading insults or making suggestive jokes with such abruptness that the emotional atmosphere struggles to recover. We appreciate characters who possess distinct personalities and senses of humor, but there are occasions when the dialogue feels more concerned with generating an amusing exchange than preserving the tension or emotional weight of the scene.

The prose itself is often colorful, energetic, and highly descriptive, particularly when the author depicts supernatural transformations, vampire feeding, or the natural beauty of British Columbia. Costelloe clearly enjoys engaging the senses, with considerable attention devoted to scents, textures, physical sensations, and the shifting colors of characters' supernatural auras. However, this descriptive enthusiasm can become excessive.

We repeatedly encounter elaborate descriptions of attractive bodies, muscular physiques, sensual lips, flowing hair, and overwhelming sexual allure, sometimes to the point that the emphasis begins to feel repetitive or unintentionally amusing. The author's fascination with the taste and aroma of blood can be similarly overindulgent, particularly when vampire feeding is described using comparisons more readily associated with wine tasting or fine dining. These passages can certainly be imaginative, but a more restrained approach would sometimes make them more effective.

We also have reservations about the story's pacing and overall narrative cohesion. There are so many competing ideas, characters, and developments that the central conflict occasionally becomes obscured. The book moves from hospital-based supernatural horror into corporate recruitment and technological intrigue, before expanding into wilderness survival, biological research, ancient legends, and increasingly elaborate confrontations.

The introduction of the Children of Sasquatch and the mysterious Dhar is certainly interesting, and we appreciate how these elements broaden the author's supernatural mythology beyond vampires alone. However, the progression from one storyline to another is not always seamless, and some developments feel as though they could support entirely separate novels. More selective plotting and tighter transitions would help the different components complement one another instead of occasionally competing for attention.

Furthermore, the novel sometimes explains its concepts more extensively than necessary. Although we appreciate the effort devoted to establishing the rules of this fictional world, conversations about vampire biology, technological systems, game development, and scientific research occasionally become exposition-heavy.

Certain characters seem to lecture one another, supplying information that is useful to readers but not always delivered in the most natural or compelling manner. We would have preferred a greater reliance on allowing these ideas to emerge organically through the characters' decisions, discoveries, and experiences. Considering how many fascinating concepts the book introduces, some additional refinement could make its storytelling considerably more efficient without sacrificing the richness of its world-building.

Beyond these literary concerns, the book's overall presentation leaves considerable room for improvement. Frankly, the copy we reviewed often looks and feels more like a work in progress than a polished, publication-ready book. The formatting is particularly rough, with conspicuous variations in typography, irregular presentation choices, and occasional expanses of blank space that interrupt the reading experience.

In some places, so much of a page is left empty that one might wonder whether additional material, an illustration, or some other element was originally intended to occupy that space. We recognize that some of this whitespace may simply result from chapter breaks or other deliberate formatting decisions, but the overall impression is still one of an unfinished manuscript that would benefit from a thorough professional review of its layout.

The typography is another concern. For example, the text abruptly changes appearance on page 66 and again around pages 107–108, creating a noticeable contrast with the surrounding material. We can understand the possible reasoning behind these decisions, particularly when the narrative introduces news broadcasts or exchanges that resemble electronic messages.

Using different fonts or formatting styles to distinguish these elements is not inherently problematic, and the author may very well have been attempting something creative. Unfortunately, the execution does not always look especially polished or visually cohesive. Instead of appearing like carefully integrated design choices, these changes can resemble inconsistencies that were overlooked during formatting. Whether intentional or accidental, the resulting presentation feels less professional than it should.

We have similar reservations about the book's extensive use of italics. Italicized text can be a valuable literary tool for distinguishing memories, dreams, internal thoughts, shifts in perspective, or other departures from the main narrative. We can generally understand why Costelloe might want to employ this technique, particularly in a story where the boundaries between memory, reality, supernatural influence, and personal identity are frequently blurred.

However, there is a considerable difference between using italics for occasional emphasis and placing entire lengthy passages, sometimes virtually entire pages, in italicized type. The latter happens repeatedly throughout this manuscript, and the effect becomes increasingly distracting and visually exhausting. What might initially seem like a creative stylistic decision eventually begins to feel overused, diminishing its effectiveness while making substantial portions of the book less comfortable to read.

These presentation issues are especially unfortunate because they are largely avoidable. We do not believe every unconventional formatting decision needs to be eliminated, nor would we want the author to abandon stylistic experimentation altogether. However, such decisions should appear deliberate, consistent, and professionally executed, with the reader's experience remaining a priority.

Here, the combined effect of excessive italics, abrupt font changes, awkward spacing, and an occasionally messy layout detracts from an otherwise imaginative story. There is a difference between a book that deliberately breaks conventions and one that simply appears insufficiently edited or formatted, and this manuscript sometimes comes uncomfortably close to the latter. We strongly encourage another comprehensive editorial and formatting pass before treating this version as a finished publication.

Jude's moral development is also interesting, although not always entirely convincing in its execution. The character expresses genuine horror at the brutality of other vampires, demonstrates compassion toward vulnerable individuals, and struggles with tremendous guilt over past actions. Yet Jude also commits terrible acts with surprisingly little reflection, including draining the life from an already seriously ill shopkeeper during the group's escape.

We recognize that this contradiction can be understood as part of the character's ongoing struggle between humanity and vampirism, and we appreciate the potential complexity of such a conflict. Nevertheless, the narrative does not always interrogate these contradictions as thoroughly as we would like, occasionally moving past troubling actions before readers have sufficient opportunity to process their consequences.

Despite these criticisms, we must commend Costelloe for his willingness to take creative risks. The book explores fascinating questions about personal freedom, the corrupting influence of power, humanity's treatment of the natural world, and the possibility of coexistence between competing forms of intelligent life. Its depiction of a supernatural hierarchy built upon exploitation also lends itself to interesting comparisons with real-world institutions and systems of power.

Meanwhile, the later developments involving the Sasquatch community, resistance against the vampire leadership, and the possibility of reversing certain transformations provide additional dimensions to a story that continually seeks to expand its imaginative boundaries. Even when we questioned the execution of a particular idea, we rarely questioned the author's enthusiasm for exploring it.

Vampires in BC is an inventive, ambitious, and frequently entertaining supernatural adventure that introduces a number of thought-provoking concepts while offering an unconventional interpretation of familiar vampire mythology. We particularly appreciate its exploration of identity, manipulation, personal freedom, and contemporary social concerns, as well as the author's willingness to address challenging subjects through the imaginative possibilities of fiction.

However, its inconsistent tone, occasionally excessive descriptions, uneven pacing, overcrowded narrative, and notably rough presentation prevent the book from achieving its full potential. There are moments when the story is genuinely unsettling or emotionally compelling, followed by others that feel too exaggerated, juvenile, or unintentionally comical for their own good. Moreover, the distracting typography and unfinished-looking formatting suggest that additional editorial attention is still needed.

Nevertheless, Costelloe has created a distinctive fictional world with considerable potential, and we recommend this book to readers who enjoy unconventional vampire fiction, elaborate supernatural mythology, and imaginative stories unafraid to venture beyond familiar genre conventions.

Check it out on Amazon!
0 Comments
<<Previous

    Archives

    November 2026
    October 2026
    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

FOLLOW OUR SOCIALS!​

Picture
Picture
Picture
  • Home
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Testimonials
  • Winners- 2026 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2026 Spring Contest
  • 2025 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- 2025 Clash of Champions
  • Winners- 2025 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2025 Spring Contest
  • 2024 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- 2024 Clash of Champions
  • Winners- 2024 Summer Contest
  • Winners- 2024 Creator Classic
  • 2023 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- Clash of Champions 2023
  • Winners- Spring 2023
  • Winners- Winter 2023
  • 2022 BOTY Awards
  • Winners- Fall 2022
  • Winners- Summer 2022
  • Winners- Spring 2022
  • Winners- Winter 2021-2022
  • Terms
  • Privacy Policy